Why Most "Leadership Training" is Useless (Here's What Actually Works)
dailyblog.scottdclary.com
Hi All,
Here’s my daily newsletter navigating the crossroads of business, growth, and life.
If you love this content (please share it), but also…
Start here > https://newsletter.scottdclary.com
Check out my Podcast, connect with me on YouTube / Twitter, and read my Weekly newsletter.
Sponsor: FreshBooks
The numbers speak for themselves - over 30 million people have chosen FreshBooks, processing more than $60 billion in invoices and saving an incredible 192 hours annually on accounting tasks. As an all-in-one accounting solution, FreshBooks helps entrepreneurs and freelancers create professional estimates, track time, automatically bill clients, and capture expenses on the go - all while integrating seamlessly with over 100 business tools and providing award-winning customer service.
Ready to stop drowning in receipts and chasing payments? Start your 30-day free trial at freshbooks.com - no credit card required.
Transform Your Business with FreshBooks
Listen Here
Why Most "Leadership Training" is Useless for Founders
You just dropped $2,000 on that founder leadership masterclass.
Your bookshelf is filled with leadership bestsellers gathering dust.
Your podcast queue is packed with "how to lead your startup team" episodes.
And none of it will prepare you for what's coming.
Real leadership is about making high-stakes decisions under pressure. Not attending seminars on emotional intelligence.
As a first-time founder, you face a unique challenge. Every founder blog, podcast, and course wants to teach you "leadership." But the gap between what they teach and what you'll actually need in the trenches is massive.
The Founder Leadership Paradox
Here's what actually happens in startups:
You'll need to fire your first employee with zero HR experience.
You'll have to decide whether to pivot your entire business model with just two months of runway left.
You'll face the moment when your technical co-founder wants to quit and take half your code with them.
And in these moments, everything you learned in that leadership course will evaporate like morning fog.
Leadership frameworks help you talk about leadership. They don't help you lead when everything is on fire.
When Brian Chesky faced the pandemic wiping out 80% of Airbnb's business overnight, he didn't pull out his notes from leadership seminars. He had to make brutal decisions that would determine whether his company survived – laying off friends while keeping others motivated during the worst crisis in company history.
No mastermind prepared him for that.
Why Conventional Leadership Advice Fails Founders
The problem isn't that leadership content contains bad information. The problem is that it lacks the essential ingredient that makes leadership real:
Skin in the game.
In leadership courses, you role-play scenarios where failure means mild embarrassment.
In founder reality, you navigate scenarios where failure means:
Missing payroll for people who trusted your vision
Watching your bank balance approach zero while investors ghost you
Explaining to early customers why your product suddenly doesn't work
Telling your partner you might need to move back in with your parents
This gap creates founders who:
Can eloquently discuss leadership theory
Completely freeze when faced with actual leadership moments
Make decisions too slowly due to overthinking frameworks
Crack under pressure when stakes are real
The worst part? Most "leadership experts" teaching these courses have never led anything more consequential than a workshop.
The Three Founder Leadership Skills That Actually Matter
After watching hundreds of early-stage founders succeed and fail, I've noticed that effective founder leadership boils down to three core capabilities:
1. Decisive Action With Minimal Information
When Tobi Lütke was building Shopify, he didn't have the luxury of complete information. Most critical decisions came with maybe 30% of the data he needed.
The reality is that founder leadership looks like:
Making the call when 6 different metrics point in different directions
Choosing between terrible options with compressed timelines
Trusting your judgment when everyone has a different opinion
Acting confidently despite massive internal uncertainty
Leadership courses teach decision frameworks that require data you won't have.
The strongest founder-leaders develop a comfort with uncertainty that no course can teach.
2. Crisis Management Under Existential Threat
Your leadership will be defined by how you handle moments of potential company death.
Consider what happened at Stripe during their early days. Just as they were gaining traction, their banking partner threatened to shut them down with almost no notice. Within 48 hours, they had to:
Design an entirely new risk management system
Negotiate with multiple new banking partners
Reassure anxious customers without revealing the full crisis
Keep the team focused despite existential uncertainty
How you respond when your company is actively dying reveals your actual leadership capability.
Most leadership content teaches from stability. Founder leadership happens in chaos.
The best founders develop crisis clarity – the ability to think clearly and act decisively when everything is falling apart.
3. Emotional Resilience Through Sustained Pressure
Founder leadership isn't a sprint or even a marathon. It's more like holding your breath underwater while swimming through a dark tunnel of unknown length.
When Bumble launched in 2014, it entered a market dominated by established competitors with billion-dollar valuations. Overnight, these giants copied Bumble's core features while leveraging their massive user bases. Meanwhile, legal challenges threatened the company's very existence.
Despite this, the team remained focused, the product improved, and they maintained their vision – not because of leadership training, but because of emotional endurance through sustained pressure.
Leadership courses teach management in ideal conditions. Founder leadership happens in perpetual turbulence.
This emotional durability separates successful founders from those who burn out despite perfect knowledge of leadership theory.
The Anti-Course: How to Actually Develop Founder Leadership
If you want to develop real founder leadership capabilities, forget courses. Do these instead:
Launch Something Small But Real
Before your main venture, create a micro-startup with:
Actual customers paying real money
A public commitment to deliver by a specific date
A small team relying on your decisions
Your own money at stake (even if just a small amount)
This creates the core conditions of founder leadership in a lower-stakes environment.
Nothing develops leadership like having skin in the game.
Early Dropbox wasn't the billion-dollar cloud storage giant we know today. It was one developer making promises to strangers on the internet, then frantically coding all night to keep those promises. That crucible—where real people would be genuinely disappointed by failure—developed leadership capabilities no course could provide.
Seek Crisis-Forged Mentors
Not all experience is created equal. The mentors you need aren't the most successful founders, but the ones who have:
Navigated near-death experiences with their startups
Made painful personnel decisions
Pivoted under extreme pressure
Faced down failure and survived
The founders with the most valuable insights often have the most battle scars.
Y Combinator advises founders to look for mentors with "scar tissue" – the marks left by difficult leadership moments that forced real growth. These battle-tested founders can share the tactical knowledge that only comes from leading through legitimate crisis.
A Final Word For First-Time Founders
The hard truth is that watching videos about founder leadership is to actually leading a startup as reading about skydiving is to jumping out of a plane.
At some point, you have to jump.
And the plane has to be high enough that the jump could kill you, or it's not really skydiving.
Unsubscribe from that founder leadership course. Instead, put yourself in situations where:
You have real skin in the game
Others are counting on your decisions
Failure has personal consequences
You can't hide from the results
That's not just how you'll learn founder leadership.
That's how you'll become the leader your startup actually needs.
Thank you for reading.
– Scott