How to Not Screw Up Your Podcast Appearance
dailyblog.scottdclary.com
Hi All,
Here’s my daily newsletter navigating the crossroads of business, growth, and life.
If you love this content (please share it), but also…
Start here > https://newsletter.scottdclary.com
Check out my Podcast, connect with me on YouTube / Twitter, and read my Weekly newsletter.
Sponsor: Lingoda
Look, I'll be real with you, my French used to be solid. I learned it in school. But when I booked a trip to France a few years ago, it was a total blank. I could barely order a croissant.
So I joined the Lingoda Sprint Challenge. And it changed everything. Live classes, five students max, real teachers. In two months, I went from bonjour to café conversations.
Here's how it works - you take 30 or 60 classes in 60 days, and when you finish, you get 50% of your money back. That works out to about $4.50 per class, which is honestly amazing for live instruction. Let's get fluent.
Listen Here
How to Not Screw Up Your Podcast Appearance
You got the email.
A podcast host wants you on their show. Your first thought: "Finally, someone recognizes my genius."
Your second thought: "What if I sound like an idiot?"
Both thoughts are dangerous.
The first makes you unprepared. The second makes you robotic.
Most founders treat podcast appearances like job interviews – formal, rehearsed, and forgettable. They spend hours memorizing talking points and company metrics, then deliver them like a PowerPoint presentation.
The result? Forty-five minutes of corporate speak that puts everyone to sleep.
Great podcast guests don't just share information. They create moments.
Moments that make listeners hit rewind. Moments that spark conversations. Moments that turn strangers into customers and customers into evangelists.
Here's how to be that guest instead of the one everyone forgets.
The Fatal Mistake 99% of Founders Make
Most founders think the goal of a podcast is to talk about their company.
Wrong.
The goal is to make the audience care about a problem they didn't know they had.
I've listened to hundreds of founder interviews. The forgettable ones follow the same script:
"Tell us about your company." "Well, we're a B2B SaaS platform that helps enterprises optimize their..."
Instant tune-out.
The memorable interviews start differently:
"Most CEOs think they're making data-driven decisions. In reality, they're making Excel-driven guesses with a 73% failure rate."
Now you have attention.
Your company story is the vehicle, not the destination. The destination is making people see their world differently.
When Brian Chesky went on podcasts in Airbnb's early days, he didn't lead with "We're a platform for peer-to-peer accommodation." He started with: "There are millions of empty bedrooms in the world while people pay $300 for tiny hotel rooms. Something's broken."
Problem first. Solution second. Company details last.
This mindset shift changes everything about how you prepare. Instead of rehearsing company facts, you need to develop materials that create those problem-first moments.
The Preparation That Actually Matters
Forget memorizing your pitch deck. Successful podcast guests prepare three specific types of content that create connection instead of confusion.
First, you need stories that prove your point
Not case studies with charts and numbers. Stories with people, problems, and resolutions.
You should have three ready:
The moment you realized the problem existed
The moment you knew your solution worked
The moment you almost gave up (and why you didn't)
Each story should take 90 seconds or less and feel like you're telling a friend, not presenting to investors. People remember stories, not statistics. When someone asks about your company, these stories let you show rather than tell.
Next, you need a perspective that challenges conventional wisdom
Every industry has accepted truths that everyone believes but few question. Your job is to identify what everyone in your space believes that's actually wrong.
This isn't about being controversial for clicks. It's about having a perspective worth sharing – one that makes people reconsider assumptions they've never examined.
Your contrarian belief should be something you can defend with evidence and experience, not just opinion.
Finally, you need practical insights people can use immediately
This is where most founders hold back, thinking they need to save their best material for paying customers. That's backwards thinking.
Give away your most valuable insights for free. The more value you provide during the interview, the more people trust you with their money later.
These insights should be specific enough that someone could implement them before the episode ends. Think tactical, not theoretical.
That's your content foundation: three stories, one contrarian belief, two tactical insights. No company timeline. No funding announcements. No feature lists.
But even the best content falls flat if you don't understand who you're talking to. Which brings us to the research that most founders skip entirely.
The Research That Makes You Confident
Most founders show up to podcasts knowing nothing about the host or audience. Then they wonder why the conversation feels awkward and off-target.
Smart preparation starts with understanding exactly who you're talking to and how they prefer to communicate.
Start by researching the host's background
Spend 20 minutes learning about them:
What's their entrepreneurial journey?
What topics do they care about most?
What's their interview style - aggressive or conversational?
What questions do they ask repeatedly across episodes?
This isn't stalking. It's professional preparation. When you reference something from their background or previous episodes, it shows respect and creates instant connection. More importantly, it helps you tailor your stories and insights to what they find most interesting.
Next, understand who's listening
Every podcast has a core audience with specific characteristics. Figure out:
Are they early-stage founders or experienced entrepreneurs?
What industries are they in?
What level of technical depth do they want?
What challenges are they currently facing?
You wouldn't give the same presentation to teenagers and CEOs. Don't give the same interview to different audiences. Your stories and examples should speak directly to the people who will be listening.
Then listen to 2-3 recent episodes
This is non-negotiable. Pay attention to:
How long are the typical answers?
What makes the host excited or engaged?
What types of stories get the best reactions?
How formal or casual is the tone?
This research helps you match the show's energy and format, making the conversation feel natural rather than forced.
Finally, prepare host-specific questions
Most interviews end with "Do you have any questions for me?" Don't waste this opportunity with generic questions.
Instead of: "What advice do you have for founders?" Try: "In episode 47, you mentioned the hardest part of scaling was hiring. What's one hiring mistake you see founders make repeatedly?"
This shows you've done your homework and often leads to the most interesting part of the conversation.
Now that you know what to say and who you're saying it to, let's address the elephant in the room: your nerves. Because all the preparation in the world won't help if anxiety derails your performance.
The Comfort Hacks That Eliminate Nerves
Even with great preparation, nerves can derail your performance. The key is creating confidence through control over everything you can control.
Start with a technical test 24 hours before
Nothing kills confidence like technical problems during recording. Test everything:
Microphone and audio quality
Internet connection stability
Recording software (if you're responsible for it)
Lighting and camera angle (for video podcasts)
Most hosts will do a brief tech check, but don't rely on this. Be ready so you can focus on the conversation, not the technology.
Practice your opening story out loud
You don't need to rehearse the entire interview, but nail your opening. Practice it until you can tell it conversationally without notes.
This gives you a confident start, which builds momentum for the rest of the conversation. When you know exactly how you'll begin, everything else flows more naturally.
Set up your environment for success
Create the ideal conditions:
Find a quiet space where you won't be interrupted
Have water nearby (room temperature, not ice cold)
Keep your prepared notes visible but not distracting
Remove or silence anything that might cause distraction
Develop your pre-interview energy routine
Figure out what gets you in the right headspace:
Some founders do light exercise beforehand
Others listen to music that pumps them up
Some prefer 10 minutes of quiet reflection
Whatever works for you, make it part of your routine. Consistency in preparation creates confidence in performance.
Remember the host wants you to succeed
They invited you because they believe you'll provide value to their audience. They're not trying to trip you up or make you look bad. Their success depends on your success.
This mindset shift alone eliminates most interview anxiety.
With your nerves under control and your preparation complete, the pressure shifts to those crucial opening moments. Because no matter how ready you are, the first minute determines whether listeners stay or skip to the next episode.
The First 60 Seconds That Make or Break Everything
The opening moments of a podcast appearance determine whether listeners stay or leave.
Most founders waste this critical window with boring biographical details:
"I'm the founder and CEO of XYZ Corp. I have an MBA from..."
Nobody cares about your credentials in the first minute. They care about whether you'll say something interesting.
Here's what actually works:
Start with a moment of recognition. Something that makes the listener think, "Yes! I've experienced that exact thing."
Instead of: "I founded a customer support platform because I saw inefficiencies in the market."
Try: "I was getting customer support emails at 3 AM and realized I had built a company that required me to be awake 24/7. Either I figured out how to scale myself, or I'd burn out before we hit our first million."
The difference? The second version creates instant connection through shared experience. Every founder has felt trapped by their own success.
Your opening should make listeners lean in, not check their phones.
Test this with friends. Tell them your opening line and watch their body language. If they don't physically lean forward or ask a follow-up question, keep refining.
Once you've hooked their attention, the real skill becomes reading between the lines of what the host is actually asking. Because the surface question is rarely the real question.
How to Answer the Question Behind the Question
Podcast hosts ask predictable questions, but they're rarely asking what they seem to be asking. They're asking for content their audience can actually use.
Surface question: "How did you get your first customers?" Real question: "What specific actions can my audience take to get their first customers?"
Surface question: "What's your biggest challenge as a founder?" Real question: "What problem do founders face that they're not talking about publicly?"
Surface question: "Where do you see your company in five years?" Real question: "What trends are you seeing that others are missing?"
Answer the real question, not the surface question.
When asked about first customers, don't just list your customer acquisition tactics. Explain the mindset shift that made those tactics possible.
"Getting our first customers wasn't about finding the right marketing channel. It was about accepting that our initial product was terrible and our first customers were actually paying us to figure out what they really needed."
This approach transforms generic interview questions into compelling content.
The host gets better material than they expected. The audience gets insights they can't find anywhere else. You get positioned as someone who thinks differently.
But answering questions well is only part of creating memorable interviews. The most powerful moments happen when guests are willing to share something real – something that shows they're human, not just a business machine.
The Art of Strategic Vulnerability
The most memorable podcast moments happen when founders show strategic vulnerability.
Not therapy-session confessions. Strategic admissions that humanize your success while teaching valuable lessons.
There's a crucial difference between helpful vulnerability and self-indulgent oversharing:
Unhelpful vulnerability: "I suffered from imposter syndrome and had panic attacks." Strategic vulnerability: "I almost shut down the company three months before our breakthrough because I was optimizing for perfection instead of customer feedback."
Strategic vulnerability includes three elements: the struggle, the lesson learned, and the outcome achieved.
It shows difficulty without creating pity. It demonstrates growth while providing actionable insight.
Your struggles aren't interesting unless they lead to wisdom others can use.
The balance is crucial. Too much vulnerability makes you seem unstable. Too little makes you seem fake.
The sweet spot: Share the specific moment you almost failed and the exact realization that turned it around.
This kind of strategic openness not only creates connection but also gives you the perfect setup for one of the most powerful podcast techniques: redirecting the conversation toward more interesting territory.
The Conversational Jujitsu That Creates Viral Moments
Great podcast guests don't just answer questions. They redirect conversations toward more valuable territory.
Instead of passively responding to whatever the host asks, you can guide the discussion toward topics that showcase your unique perspective.
The Perspective Flip:
Host: "How did you scale your team?" You: "That's the wrong question. The right question is: How did I stop being the bottleneck that prevented my team from scaling?"
The Hidden Assumption Challenge:
Host: "What's your advice for raising funding?" You: "I think most founders are asking the wrong question. Instead of 'How do I raise money?' they should ask 'How do I build something so valuable that investors compete to give me money?'"
The Industry Truth Bomb:
Host: "What trends are you excited about?" You: "Honestly? I'm more interested in what trends everyone's chasing that are about to become irrelevant."
These techniques create the moments that get clipped and shared on social media.
The goal isn't to be difficult. It's to elevate the conversation beyond surface-level Q&A.
When you consistently redirect toward deeper insights, hosts appreciate the upgrade and audiences remember the exchange.
The Follow-Up That Separates Pros from Amateurs
The interview itself is just the beginning. What separates professional podcast guests from amateurs is what happens after the recording stops.
Most founders treat podcast appearances as one-time events. They do the interview, share it once on social media, and move on.
This wastes 80% of the opportunity.
Smart founders understand that the real value comes from building relationships and creating ongoing content from a single interview.
Immediate follow-up (within 24 hours): Thank the host personally. Share one additional resource that expands on something you discussed.
Content amplification (when the episode goes live): Create multiple pieces of content from the interview. Quote your best insights. Turn stories into posts. Extract tactical advice into threads.
Relationship development (ongoing): Connect with the host on social media. Share their other content. Introduce them to relevant people in your network.
Community engagement (if possible): Respond to comments on the episode. Answer questions from listeners. Continue conversations that started during the interview.
The interview is just the beginning of the relationship, not the end.
The Long Game
Your first podcast appearance probably won't be perfect. Neither will your second or third.
The goal isn't perfection. It's progression.
Each interview teaches you something about storytelling, positioning, and audience connection. Apply those lessons to the next appearance. Refine your stories. Sharpen your insights. Improve your delivery.
The founders who become go-to podcast guests aren't necessarily the most charismatic. They're the ones who consistently provide value, think differently, and make conversations better than they would have been otherwise.
That's a skill you can build.
Start with preparation. Focus on serving the audience. Tell stories that matter. Share insights that help.
Do this consistently, and podcast invitations will shift from opportunities you hope for to opportunities you have to decline.
The best founders don't just build great companies. They become great storytellers of why those companies needed to exist.
Master that, and the podcasts will take care of themselves.
Thank you for reading.
– Scott