'Pre-totyping' Your Ideas: Validating Concepts Before Building Anything
dailyblog.scottdclary.com
Hi All,
Here’s my daily newsletter navigating the crossroads of business, growth, and life.
If you love this content (please share it), but also…
Check out my Podcast, connect with me on YouTube / Twitter, or subscribe to my weekly newsletter.
Sponsor: Angel & Accel Conf
I’m co-hosting the Zoom Conf with 1,000+ angels, VCs, family offices, and startup founders on August 28th, starting at 12 PM ET for 4 hours (join any time).
Speakers from Techstars, AngelList, Antler, HustleFund, Idealab, Everywhere Ventures, B Capital, PSL, The Council, SparkLabs Group, +50 other VCs. Moderated by journalists from TechCrunch, Business Insider, & The Information.
Register here: https://inniches.com/angel
Some registration stats: 433 Angels, 118 Syndicates, 114 LPs, 282 VCs, 792 Founders, 162 Accelerators, 116 Family Offices, 150 Exited Founders, 289 Venture Studios. 480+ investors are looking for more deal flow from other investors. 565+ investors can share their deal flow.
Hey Entrepreneurs,
Today we’re diving into a game-changing concept that could revolutionize how you approach innovation and product development.
We’re talking about ‘pre-totyping’ — a methodology so cutting-edge, it makes traditional prototyping look like old news.
The Pre-totyping Revolution
Let’s start with a thought-provoking question: What if you could validate your business ideas before investing significant time or money?
That’s where pre-totyping comes in. It’s the art and science of testing the initial appeal and actual usage of a potential new product by simulating its core experience with minimal investment.
Think of it as the lean startup methodology amplified, combined with a deep understanding of user behavior and a dash of creative problem-solving. It’s about getting to the heart of your idea’s viability faster and more efficiently than ever before.
Why Pre-totyping Matters
In our fast-paced world, time is your most valuable asset. Traditional prototyping, while useful, often requires significant investment. Pre-totyping flips this model, allowing you to:
Validate ideas quickly
Minimize sunk costs
Iterate rapidly based on real-world feedback
Identify potential pivots early in the process
But here’s the real kicker: pre-totyping isn’t just about saving time and money. It’s about fundamentally changing how we approach innovation.
The Pre-totyping Mindset Shift
To truly embrace pre-totyping, we need to rewire our entrepreneurial thinking. Here’s the shift:
From “Build it and they will come” to “Validate before you create”
From “Perfection paralysis” to “Progress through action”
From “Guessing what customers want” to “Observing what customers do”
This mindset shift is crucial because it forces us to confront our assumptions head-on. It’s about moving from the world of “I think” to the world of “I know.”
The Pre-totyping Framework: VIRAL
To help you implement pre-totyping in your own ventures, I’ve developed a framework called VIRAL:
V — Visualize the core experience
I — Identify key assumptions
R — Rapid simulation creation
A — Analyze real-world behavior
L — Learn and iterate
Let’s break this down:
Visualize the Core Experience
Start by distilling your idea to its essence. What’s the core value proposition? What’s the key interaction that defines your product or service?
For example, if you’re thinking of launching a new fitness app, the core experience might be “daily personalized workouts.” Your goal is to simulate this experience in the simplest way possible.
Identify Key Assumptions
List out all the assumptions underlying your idea. These might include:
Target audience demographics
User pain points
Willingness to pay
Frequency of use
Key features
Prioritize these assumptions based on their potential impact and how uncertain you are about them. Focus on validating the most critical assumptions first.
Rapid Simulation Creation
This is where the magic happens. Your goal is to create the simplest possible simulation of your core experience. The key is to do this quickly and cheaply.
Some pre-totyping techniques include:
The Fake Door Test: Create a landing page or ad for your non-existent product and measure click-through rates or sign-ups.
The Wizard of Oz: Manually provide the service behind the scenes, simulating an automated process.
The Concierge MVP: Offer a highly personalized version of your service to a small group of users, doing everything manually.
The Piecemeal MVP: Cobble together existing tools and services to simulate your product’s functionality.
The Paper Prototype: Create a physical, interactive model of your digital product using paper and basic art supplies.
Let’s explore some more advanced techniques:
The Reverse Engineer: Find a similar product in a different industry and adapt it to your target market. This allows you to leverage existing user behavior patterns.
The Time Travel Test: Create a “future press release” announcing your product’s success. Share it with potential customers and gauge their reactions. This technique can help you articulate your vision and test market reception simultaneously.
The Behavioral Proxy: Identify an existing behavior that closely mimics the core interaction of your product. Study and measure this behavior to gain insights into potential user adoption.
The Micro-Commitment Cascade: Design a series of increasingly committed actions for potential users. Analyze drop-off rates at each stage to identify potential friction points in your user journey.
The Synthetic A/B Test: Create two or more variations of your pre-totype, each emphasizing different value propositions or features. Test these simultaneously to identify which resonates most with your target audience.
Analyze Real-World Behavior
Once your pre-totype is live, it’s time to gather data. Focus on behavioral data over opinional data. What people do is far more telling than what they say they’ll do.
Key metrics to track might include:
Click-through rates
Time spent engaging with the pre-totype
Completion rates of key actions
Referral rates
Follow-up inquiries
Don’t stop at quantitative data. Implement tools for qualitative feedback as well:
User interviews
Screen recordings of interactions
Heat maps of user activity
Open-ended surveys
The goal is to build a comprehensive picture of how potential users interact with your core experience.
Learn and Iterate
Armed with real-world data, it’s time to learn and iterate. This is where the true power of pre-totyping shines. Because you’ve invested minimal resources, you can pivot quickly based on your findings.
Ask yourself:
Did users engage with the core experience as expected?
Which assumptions were validated or invalidated?
What unexpected behaviors or feedback emerged?
How can we refine our value proposition based on these insights?
Use these learnings to iterate on your pre-totype or, if necessary, pivot to a new concept altogether.
Conclusion: The Pre-totyping Mindset
As we wrap up this deep dive into pre-totyping, remember that at its core, this methodology is about more than just techniques or frameworks. It’s about cultivating a mindset of curiosity, humility, and relentless experimentation.
The pre-totyping mindset acknowledges that no matter how brilliant we think our ideas are, they’re ultimately hypotheses waiting to be tested. It embraces uncertainty and views “failures” as valuable data points on the path to innovation.
By adopting pre-totyping, you’re not just changing how you validate ideas — you’re transforming how you think about innovation itself. You’re moving from a world of “build and hope” to one of “learn and adapt.”
So, I challenge you to take this pre-totyping mindset and apply it to your next big idea. Embrace the uncertainty, get creative with your simulations, and let real-world behavior be your guide.
Remember, in the world of innovation, those who learn fastest, win. And pre-totyping? It’s your secret weapon for accelerating that learning process.
Now go forth and pre-totype your way to success!
Scott