Scaling Your Startup Without Losing Culture
dailyblog.scottdclary.com
Hi All,
Here’s my daily newsletter navigating the crossroads of business, growth, and life.
If you love this content (please share it), but also…
Start here > https://newsletter.scottdclary.com
Check out my Podcast, connect with me on YouTube / Twitter, and read my Weekly newsletter.
Sponsor: NordVPN
The numbers speak for themselves - NordVPN protects over 14 million users with more than 7,100 servers across 118 countries, saving countless hours of buffering and providing peace of mind. As an all-in-one security solution, NordVPN helps travelers, families, and tech enthusiasts encrypt their connections with one click, change virtual locations easily, and protect up to 10 devices simultaneously - all while offering lightning-fast speeds and award-winning Threat Protection Pro features.
Ready to stop worrying about your online privacy and access your favorite content from anywhere? Start your risk-free trial with NordVPN's 30-day money-back guarantee.
Plus, if you act now, get an exclusive listener offer of 4 extra months on the 2-year plan at nordvpn.com/success - the link is in the episode description.
Transform Your Online Experience with NordVPN
Scaling Your Startup Without Losing Culture
The Death of Culture Isn't an Accident
Most founders think culture dies by accident.
It doesn't.
Culture dies by design. Through a thousand tiny decisions that seemed right at the time. Through choosing what was easy over what was right. Through forgetting why you started in the first place.
And the worst part? You won't notice until it's too late.
When Reed Hastings started Netflix, he built a culture of freedom and responsibility. No vacation policy. No expense policy. Hire the best, pay them well, and trust them to do the right thing.
But as Netflix grew, pressure mounted to add controls. Track vacation days. Implement expense reports. Add layers of management.
Hastings refused.
Instead, he wrote the famous Netflix Culture Deck. Not as a set of aspirational values to hang on a wall, but as a warning to potential hires. If you want traditional corporate structure, don't work here.
The result? Netflix scaled from a DVD-by-mail service to a global streaming giant without losing its soul. They did it by making hard choices about who they were and weren't.
But most founders aren't willing to make those choices.
They cave to pressure from investors who want "professional management."
They compromise their values for the sake of growth.
They implement systems that kill the very spirit that made them special.
And they do it all with the best intentions.
Here's what nobody tells you about scaling culture: It's not about systems. It's about choices.
Every decision you make either strengthens or weakens your culture. There's no middle ground.
When you hire someone who's "qualified" but doesn't share your values, you're choosing to weaken your culture.
When you implement a policy because "that's what growing companies do," you're choosing to dilute what makes you special.
When you prioritize short-term growth over long-term vision, you're choosing to become what you set out to replace.
The good news? You can make different choices.
Your Culture Is Already Dead (And You Don't Know It)
The signs are subtle at first.
Your original team stops speaking up in meetings. They roll their eyes at new initiatives instead of challenging them openly. The energy that made your early days special starts to fade.
New hires don't quite get it. They're qualified on paper, but something's missing. They treat your startup like any other job.
You tell yourself it's normal. Growing pains. Part of scaling.
It's not.
Look at what happened at Zappos. Tony Hsieh built a company famous for its quirky culture and fanatical customer service. But in 2013, something changed.
They implemented a new management system called Holacracy. On paper, it was perfect. Self-organizing teams. No traditional managers. Maximum autonomy.
But it wasn't Zappos.
The system wasn't the problem. The disconnect was.
Long-time employees started leaving. The famous "quit now" bonus got more takers than ever. The culture that made Zappos special began to crack.
Why? Because they tried to systematize what should have remained organic.
Here's what nobody talks about: Culture doesn't scale through systems. It scales through stories.
Not the kind of stories you put in your pitch deck.
The real ones. The ones your team tells each other when no one's listening. The ones about that time the CEO stayed up all night helping a junior dev fix a bug. The ones about turning down a huge client because they treated your team poorly.
These stories are your real culture deck.
And right now, what stories are being told in your company?
Are they about how things used to be better? About how the "old days" were more fun, more meaningful, more real?
That's not nostalgia. That's cultural decay.
The key question isn't "How do we preserve our culture as we scale?"
It's "How do we make our culture stronger through scale?"
Because here's the brutal truth: If your culture isn't getting stronger as you grow, it's getting weaker. There's no standing still.
The Growth Trap No One Talks About
Every founder falls into this trap at some point.
You start chasing growth for growth's sake.
Your metrics look good. Your investors are happy. Your LinkedIn posts get more engagement.
But something feels off.
It starts with small compromises. Taking on clients who aren't quite right. Hiring people who are qualified but don't share your vision. Making decisions based on what looks good in your next funding round rather than what's right for your team.
Before you know it, you're optimizing for the wrong things.
Look at Etsy's journey. They built a marketplace for artisans and craftspeople. A community that valued handmade over mass-produced. Quality over quantity.
Then in 2015, they changed their policies to allow manufactured goods. The reason? Growth.
The results were predictable.
Original sellers left in droves. The platform that once stood for authentic, handcrafted goods became just another marketplace. Their stock plummeted. The very thing that made them special - their commitment to artisans - was sacrificed on the altar of scale.
It took years and a new CEO to bring back their focus on craftsmanship and community.
The trap isn't growth itself. It's thoughtless growth. Growth that serves the wrong master.
Growth should strengthen your culture, not dilute it.
But most founders have this backwards. They think scaling means becoming more "professional." More corporate. More like everyone else.
They adopt rigid hierarchies because that's what big companies do.
They implement performance reviews because that's what their investors expect.
They create departments and silos because that's what scaling means.
Right?
Wrong.
Real scale isn't about becoming a different company. It's about becoming more of who you already are.
When Patagonia grows, they don't compromise their environmental mission - they double down on it. They don't just talk about sustainability. They repair customers' old clothes instead of selling them new ones. They tell people not to buy their products unless they need them.
That's what authentic scale looks like.
It's not about adding complexity. It's about deepening your commitment to what matters.
Culture isn't what you say. It's what you're willing to sacrifice for.
And that's where most founders fail the test. They aren't willing to sacrifice growth for values. Short-term profits for long-term vision. Easy wins for hard principles.
Intentional Scaling: The Way Out
The solution isn't to stop growing.
It's to grow with intent.
Basecamp's Jason Fried and David Heinemeier Hansson made waves when they announced they'd stay small on purpose. Not because they couldn't grow bigger - they turned down millions in venture capital - but because they wanted to protect what made them special.
They chose to optimize for calm over chaos.
Most founders would call this crazy. Leaving money on the table. Missing opportunities.
But here's what they understood: Size is a choice, not a destiny.
When you strip away all the fancy business speak, scaling culture comes down to three decisions:
What you'll never compromise on
Who you let through the door
What you reward
That's it.
Everything else is just noise.
Take Costco's decision to keep their hot dog and soda combo at $1.50 since 1985. When their CEO suggested raising the price, Jim Sinegal famously replied: "If you raise the price of the hot dog, I will kill you. Figure it out."
This wasn't about hot dogs. It was about a promise to customers. About choosing values over easy profits.
But here's what makes intentional scaling hard: You have to choose what to break.
Some things that worked at 10 people won't work at 50. Some traditions that made sense at 50 won't scale to 500.
The trick isn't preserving everything. It's knowing what to keep and what to let go.
Spotify didn't try to maintain their startup vibe as they grew. Instead, they created the "squad model" - small, autonomous teams that could move fast and own decisions. They didn't preserve their old culture. They evolved it.
This is what intentional scaling looks like:
Not blindly maintaining what worked before. Not thoughtlessly adopting what works for others. But consciously choosing what serves your vision.
The key is to break things before they break you.
You know those all-hands meetings where everyone used to share updates? They probably won't work at 100 people. Break them before they become a chore.
Those informal Friday beers? They might not make sense across multiple offices. Replace them before they fade away.
That "flat" organization? It might need more structure. Add it before chaos forces your hand.
But here's the critical part: Replace them with something better.
Maybe those all-hands meetings become weekly team demos where real work gets shared.
Maybe Friday beers become quarterly team offsites where real connections get made.
Maybe that flat organization becomes a network of empowered teams.
The New Rules of Scale
Let's get practical.
Because theory doesn't help when you're in the trenches, trying to figure out if that new hire is going to strengthen or weaken your culture.
Stripe's approach to scaling changed how tech companies think about growth. Instead of traditional departments, they created small, full-stack teams that owned entire pieces of the business. Each team was a mini-startup within Stripe.
But the genius wasn't in the structure. It was in the principles behind it.
Here's what actually works when scaling culture:
First, small teams become more important as you get bigger, not less.
Culture lives in daily interactions, not company-wide announcements. Keep teams small enough that everyone knows each other's names. Large enough to be effective, small enough to care.
When GitLab scaled to over 1300 people working remotely, they didn't try to maintain the intimacy of a small company. Instead, they made transparency their superpower. Every meeting, every decision, every document became public by default.
They didn't fight scale. They used it.
Second, your onboarding process is your culture in action.
Most companies treat onboarding as orientation. Here's your laptop. Here's your desk. Here are our values on the wall.
That's garbage.
When Airbnb onboards new employees, they send them to stay in Airbnbs and host guests themselves. They don't tell people about their culture. They make them live it.
Third, documentation should capture principles, not prescriptions.
Netflix's expense policy is five words: "Act in Netflix's best interest."
That's it.
No limits. No approval process. No forms to fill out.
But it only works because they hire people who can handle that freedom.
Which brings us to the fourth rule: Hire for culture add, not culture fit.
Culture fit is how you build a monoculture. Culture add is how you build something that lasts.
You don't need people who fit your current culture. You need people who will make it stronger. Look for shared values expressed in different ways.
When DuckDuckGo hires, they look for people who care about privacy - but not just in tech. They hire activists, policy experts, educators. People who approach privacy from different angles.
That diversity of perspective makes their culture stronger, not weaker.
Finally, build feedback loops that matter.
Most companies track what's easy to measure, not what's important. Revenue, headcount, user growth.
But what about the metrics that reflect your values?
How many of your decisions get reversed because they didn't align with your principles? How often do junior team members challenge senior leaders? What percentage of your time is spent building versus fixing?
These are harder to measure. But they tell you if your culture is getting stronger or weaker as you scale.
Culture Is What You Reward
Here's where most culture initiatives die.
Not in the grand vision. Not in the fancy values statements.
But in the daily choices about what gets rewarded.
When HubSpot's CEO Brian Halligan realized their culture was drifting, he didn't write a new mission statement. He changed their compensation structure.
He made culture a number.
Not in some vague, feel-good way. But in hard metrics that affected people's pay and promotions.
Team collaboration became as important as individual performance. Long-term customer success outweighed short-term sales. Teaching others multiplied your impact score.
The results? Their culture got stronger as they scaled, not weaker.
Because here's what most founders miss: Your culture isn't your values.
It's what happens when values meet reality.
You can't claim to value work-life balance while promoting people who work 80-hour weeks.
You can't preach innovation while punishing failed experiments.
You can't talk about transparency while keeping critical information hidden.
Your rewards system is your real culture.
This goes beyond compensation. What behaviors get praised in meetings? Who gets promoted? What stories get told about success?
This is what will impact your culture as you scale.
The Path Forward
So where do you go from here?
Start with three questions:
What are you really rewarding? Not what you say you reward. What actually gets people ahead in your company? Write it down. Be honest.
What makes someone successful here? Again, not the job description version. The real version. The unwritten rules that everyone knows but no one talks about.
What stories get told? When people talk about wins, what do those stories celebrate? Individual brilliance or team effort? Short-term gains or long-term thinking?
Then make one change.
Just one.
Find the biggest gap between what you say you value and what you actually reward.
Fix that first.
Because here's the truth about scaling culture:
It's not about becoming a different company.
It's about becoming more of who you already are.
Just bigger.
And a hell of a lot clearer about what matters.
– Scott