Stop Losing Customers
dailyblog.scottdclary.com
Hi All,
Here’s my daily newsletter navigating the crossroads of business, growth, and life.
If you love this content (please share it), but also…
Start here > https://stan.store/scottdclary
Check out my Podcast, connect with me on YouTube / Twitter, and read my Weekly newsletter.
Sponsor: FreshBooks
The numbers speak for themselves - over 30 million people have chosen FreshBooks, processing more than $60 billion in invoices and saving an incredible 192 hours annually on accounting tasks. As an all-in-one accounting solution, FreshBooks helps entrepreneurs and freelancers create professional estimates, track time, automatically bill clients, and capture expenses on the go - all while integrating seamlessly with over 100 business tools and providing award-winning customer service.
Ready to stop drowning in receipts and chasing payments? Start your 30-day free trial at freshbooks.com - no credit card required.
Plus, if you act before January 7th, get an exclusive Success Story listener offer of 75% off your first three months at freshbooks.com/pricing-offer.
Transform Your Business with FreshBooks
End the High Churn
Most entrepreneurs are lying to themselves about growth.
You see it everywhere. Instagram feeds full of hockey stick graphs. LinkedIn posts bragging about new customer counts. TechCrunch headlines celebrating the latest funding round.
But behind closed doors, these same companies are hemorrhaging customers faster than they can replace them.
The dirty secret? Most "successful" businesses are just better at hiding their churn.
The numbers tell a brutal story. The average SaaS company loses 5-7% of their customers every month. Ecommerce? Even worse. Subscription boxes can see monthly churn rates above 10%.
This isn't just about lost revenue. Every customer who leaves is taking something far more valuable than their money. They're taking:
The trust you spent months building
The acquisition costs you'll never recover
The social proof you desperately need
The momentum that keeps your team motivated
But here's what makes it truly dangerous.
Most businesses respond to churn by doubling down on acquisition. More ads. More content. More sales calls. They're trying to fill a bucket that's full of holes.
Do the math. At 5% monthly churn, you need to replace half your customer base every single year just to stay flat. Want to grow? Now you need even more customers.
This creates a vicious cycle. The more you focus on acquisition, the less attention you pay to retention. The less attention you pay to retention, the more customers you lose.
It's the equivalent of trying to save a relationship by going on more first dates.
But there's a massive opportunity hidden in this mess.
While your competitors chase new logos and burn cash on acquisition, you can build a moat that gets deeper every month. Not through fancy features or growth hacks. But through a systematic approach to keeping the customers you already have.
The solution isn't complicated. But it requires you to think differently about your business.
Stop Building What Nobody Wants
Your customers aren't leaving because of your competition.
They're leaving because you're solving the wrong problem.
I see this mistake constantly. A business starts losing customers, and their first instinct is to add more features. More options. More complexity. They think if they just build that one thing, people will finally stick around.
But adding features to a product nobody wants just creates a bigger product nobody wants.
The hard truth? Most businesses don't have a product problem. They have a value problem.
Basecamp is the perfect example. They compete in one of the most crowded markets imaginable - project management. Their competitors have more features, more integrations, and bigger budgets.
Yet Basecamp maintains incredible retention rates. Why? Because they understand their retention core.
Your retention core is the transformation that makes customers stick around month after month.
It's not about what your product does. It's about what changes in your customer's life or business when they use it. Basecamp doesn't just help you manage projects. They make chaos feel manageable. That's their retention core.
Finding yours means asking uncomfortable questions:
What problem makes customers pull out their credit card without hesitation?
Which customers stay the longest, and what exactly do they use your product for?
If you could only solve one problem perfectly, what would create the most loyalty?
A gym owner I know discovered his retention core by accident. He thought people stayed for the equipment and training programs. But when he surveyed his longest-term members, he found something surprising.
They stayed because his gym was the only place they felt comfortable working out without judgment. That insight completely changed his business. He stopped competing on equipment and started focusing on creating the most welcoming environment in town.
His churn rate dropped by 60% in six months.
Your best customers are already telling you what your retention core is. You just haven't been listening.
Look at your product through this lens. Strip away all the extra features. What's the one transformation that your loyal customers can't live without?
That's where you start.
Make it Impossible to Leave
Let's get something straight.
When I say "impossible to leave," I'm not talking about dark patterns or contract lock-in. That's amateur hour. It's also the fastest way to breed resentment and tank your reputation.
True customer lock-in happens when leaving costs more than staying.
And I don't mean money.
Think about Shopify for a moment. They're not just powering online stores. They've become the central nervous system for millions of businesses. Their customers build entire operations around them. Payment processing. Inventory management. Customer relationships. Marketing automation.
Leaving Shopify means rebuilding your entire business infrastructure. That's real lock-in.
But here's what most people miss about Shopify's strategy. They don't force you to use their ecosystem. They make it the obvious choice.
Every new tool they add makes the previous ones more valuable. Each integration makes switching more painful. Not because they trap you, but because they solve real problems in connected ways.
You don't need to be Shopify to create this effect.
Let’s use meal prep as an example.
Meal prep is an industry where customers constantly hop between services.
How do you differentiate yourself?
Turn meal prep into a lifestyle ecosystem.
Beyond the meals, customers get access to:
A private community where they share progress
Monthly check-ins with nutritionists
Customized workout plans that sync with their meal schedule
Each element makes the whole service more valuable. Leave the meal prep, and you lose the community. Lose the community, and you lose the accountability that's helping you hit your goals.
This is ecosystem value in action. The product becomes more valuable the longer customers use it. Not through points or rewards, but through genuine transformation.
Look at your business. What assets do customers build while using your product? What relationships do they form? What systems do they create?
The deeper these connections go, the harder it becomes for competitors to replicate your value.
Maybe it's templates your customers customize over time. Or workflows they build with their team. Or data that becomes more valuable the longer it accumulates.
Find these leverage points and strengthen them. Turn them into moats that get deeper with every customer interaction.
Because when you do this right, customers don't stay because they have to. They stay because leaving means giving up value they can't get anywhere else.
That's the kind of lock-in worth building.
Turn Support From Cost to Profit Center
Your support team isn't just handling tickets.
They're sitting on a goldmine of retention data that most businesses completely ignore.
Think about it. Support is the only team that talks to your customers every single day. They hear the real problems, the actual use cases, and most importantly, the early warning signs of churn.
But most companies get this completely wrong.
They optimize for closing tickets instead of understanding patterns. They measure response times instead of customer outcomes. They treat support as damage control rather than intelligence gathering.
Every support interaction is telling you something crucial about your business. The question is whether you're listening.
A software company I know transformed their support team from a cost center into their primary retention engine. Their secret? They stopped treating tickets as problems to solve and started seeing them as signals to analyze.
They discovered something fascinating.
Customers who asked certain types of questions were 80% more likely to cancel within 60 days. These weren't complaints. They were subtle signs of misalignment between what customers expected and what they were getting.
Armed with this insight, they built an early warning system:
When customers trigger specific support patterns, it automatically kicks off a retention protocol. Their team reaches out proactively, addressing the underlying issues before they become reasons to leave.
Their churn rate dropped by 43% in the first quarter.
But here's where it gets really interesting.
The same data showed them which customers were most likely to expand their accounts. Certain support interactions actually predicted growth, not churn.
Now their support team doesn't just prevent cancellations. They actively identify and nurture expansion opportunities.
This isn't complicated. You don't need fancy AI or machine learning. You just need to start tracking the right signals:
What questions do customers ask right before they churn?
Which feature requests indicate misalignment with your ideal customer profile?
What patterns of usage or support interaction predict long-term success?
The best retention strategies often come from support conversations, not boardroom meetings.
Your support team is already gathering this intelligence. They just need the systems and permission to use it.
Start treating every customer interaction as valuable data. Build processes to capture and analyze it. Then use those insights to get ahead of problems before they become cancellations.
That's how you turn a cost center into a profit engine.
Build a Churn Prevention System
Everything we've covered means nothing without a system.
Because here's the truth about churn. It's not an event. It's a process.
Customers don't wake up one day and decide to leave. They show you they're leaving long before they hit the cancel button. But most businesses don't notice until it's too late.
You need a system that catches risks before they become cancellations.
But this isn't about building some complex tech stack or hiring a team of data scientists. It's about paying attention to the right signals at the right time.
Here's what that looks like in practice.
First, identify your leading indicators. These are the behaviors that predict churn before it happens:
Usage patterns dropping below certain thresholds
Missing key features in their workflow
Support tickets about specific issues
Engagement dropping with your ecosystem
Payment issues or downgrades
Next, create trigger points. Specific moments when your team steps in to address these risks.
An ecommerce brand I work with saw their subscription retention jump 35% after implementing a simple trigger system. When customers skip two deliveries in a row, it automatically flags their account for a personalized reach-out.
They don't try to sell. They ask questions. They understand what's changed. Then they either solve the real problem or help the customer transition out gracefully.
Because here's another truth. Not all churn is bad.
Some customers should leave. Either because they're not a good fit, or because your business has evolved, or because their needs have changed.
The goal isn't to save every customer. It's to save the right ones.
This is where most churn prevention systems fail. They treat every cancellation as a problem to solve rather than a signal to learn from.
Your system needs three core elements:
Clear indicators that tell you which customers are at risk
Specific actions your team takes when those indicators appear
Feedback loops that help you improve the system over time
But the most important part? You have to actually use it.
I've seen businesses build elaborate retention systems that never get implemented. They sit in Notion docs and spreadsheets while customers continue to slip away.
Start simple. Pick one leading indicator. Create one intervention. Measure the results.
Then build from there.
Because here's the biggest opportunity in business right now.
While your competitors chase new logos and burn cash on acquisition, you can build a base of customers who stick around for years. Who tell others about you. Who make your business stronger every month they stay.
That's not just good business. It's an unfair advantage.
Your existing customers are your biggest opportunity for growth. They already trust you. They're already paying you. They're already getting value.
Keep them happy, and they'll build your business for you.
– Scott