The Customer Success Playbook
dailyblog.scottdclary.com
Hi All,
Here’s my daily newsletter navigating the crossroads of business, growth, and life.
If you love this content (please share it), but also…
Start here > https://newsletter.scottdclary.com
Check out my Podcast, connect with me on YouTube / Twitter, and read my Weekly newsletter.
Sponsor: Vanta
Security is essential for business success. Without it, deals stall and scaling becomes difficult because investors, customers, and partners expect strong security practices.
Vanta helps businesses prove trustworthiness by automating compliance across 35+ frameworks like SOC 2, ISO 27001, and HIPAA. Their platform:
Automates up to 90% of compliance work
Speeds up security questionnaire responses by 5x
Connects you with security experts
An IDC report found Vanta customers achieve $535,000+ in annual benefits with the platform paying for itself in just three months.
Special offer: Get $1,000 off Vanta for a limited time at vanta.com/Scott.
Listen Here
Customer Success Is Your Secret Growth Engine
Let me tell you about a transformation I witnessed firsthand.
A SaaS founder I know was obsessed with acquisition. New logos. Fresh leads. The dopamine hit of closing deals.
Meanwhile, his existing customers were silently slipping away.
His churn rate? A staggering 18% monthly.
Do the math on that. It means he was losing nearly his entire customer base every 6 months.
But here's the wild part—he kept growing. The acquisition machine was so strong that despite the leaky bucket, revenue kept climbing... until it didn't.
One quarter, growth flatlined. The next, it reversed.
In desperation, he finally did what advisors had been telling him to do for months:
He built a real customer success function.
Six months later, churn dropped to 3%. Twelve months later, expansion revenue (getting existing customers to pay more) exceeded new customer revenue.
The same business. The same product. Completely different trajectory.
Here's what most early-stage founders miss:
Customer success isn't just support with a fancy name. It's a strategic growth engine.
And I'm going to break down exactly how to build one, even if you're just getting started.
The High-Stakes Reality Most Founders Miss
Let's get something clear upfront.
In the early days of your business, you're probably obsessed with two things:
Building a product people want
Getting people to try that product
That's completely natural. Without those things, you don't have a business.
But there's a dangerous assumption that sneaks into your thinking:
"If the product is good, customers will stick around and grow with us."
That assumption is killing your business.
Here's the truth that Nick Mehta, CEO of Gainsight and the godfather of customer success, discovered after working with thousands of companies:
Even with an amazing product, customers will churn if they don't achieve their desired outcomes.
And achieving outcomes rarely happens automatically—especially for complex or transformative products.
Think about your own experience. How many software tools have you signed up for, used a couple times, then abandoned? Was it because the tool was bad? Or because you never fully integrated it into your workflow?
For most of us, it's the latter.
Now multiply that behavior across your entire customer base. That's the default scenario you're fighting against.
This isn't just theory. The data is brutal:
For SaaS businesses, a 5% improvement in customer retention translates to a 25-95% increase in profits.
The cost of acquiring a new customer is 5-25x higher than retaining an existing one.
Existing customers are 50% more likely to try new products and spend 31% more compared to new customers.
But here's the most important number of all:
For the average business, 80% of your future revenue will come from just 20% of your existing customers.
So yes, keep building and selling. But if you're not equally focused on customer success, you're leaving your company's future to chance.
The Three Phases Every Customer Relationship Goes Through
Before we dive into tactics, you need to understand the fundamental structure of customer relationships.
Every customer journey, regardless of your product, service, or industry, moves through three distinct phases:
Onboarding - Getting the customer from purchase to first value
Adoption - Expanding usage and integrating into their workflow or life
Growth - Deepening the relationship and expanding the partnership
Most founders interact with these phases backwards. They invest heavily in growth conversations (upselling, cross-selling) while neglecting the foundational onboarding and adoption work that makes growth possible.
This is like trying to harvest fruit from a tree you haven't watered.
Let's break down each phase and the specific interventions that drive success.
Phase 1: Onboarding — The Make-or-Break Moment
You've probably heard the term "time to value" before. It's the interval between when a customer purchases from you and when they experience the primary benefit.
What you might not know is that this interval is the single biggest predictor of long-term retention.
The faster a customer reaches their first meaningful outcome with your offering, the more likely they are to become a long-term advocate.
I've seen this play out repeatedly. Two customers buy the exact same thing. One gets value in the first 48 hours. The other takes two weeks. Six months later, guess which one is still a customer?
Time to value isn't about rushing. It's about removing obstacles.
Here are the specific interventions Mehta recommends during onboarding:
1. The Welcome Call
This isn't a courtesy—it's a strategic necessity. Within 24 hours of purchase, have a real human being (even if that's you as the founder) reach out to:
Thank them for their business
Reiterate the specific outcome they're trying to achieve
Set clear expectations for the next steps
Introduce their dedicated point of contact
For very low-price products, this can be automated with video. But remember: the higher the price point, the more human touch is required.
2. The Success Plan
This is where rubber meets road. Together with your customer, create a simple document that defines:
What "success" looks like for them specifically
The timeline for achieving initial and ongoing value
The resources required from both sides
Potential obstacles and how you'll address them
If you're just starting out, don't overthink this. A simple Google Doc with these four elements is enough. As you grow, you can build this into your product or a specialized platform.
3. The Configuration Sprint
Whatever initial setup is required for your offering, treat it like a sprint. Set a clear timeframe (ideally under a week), outline the specific tasks, and check in daily on progress.
The goal isn't perfection—it's momentum.
I worked with a founder who reduced their onboarding time from three weeks to three days by simply breaking the process into small daily tasks and creating accountability around each one.
4. The Value Milestone
This is absolutely critical. Define a clear, measurable moment when the customer has received initial value from what you offer, and celebrate it explicitly.
This could be:
Their first completed project
Their first successful use case
Their first tangible result
Their first dollar saved or earned
Whatever it is, make it concrete and make a big deal about it. Send an email. Give them a badge. Call them personally.
This "moment of value" creates a psychological anchor that dramatically increases the odds of long-term retention.
Phase 2: Adoption — From Novelty to Necessity
This is where most customer relationships go to die.
The initial excitement has worn off. The daily demands of work have kicked in. And your offering, despite its potential value, starts to feel like "one more thing" in an already overwhelming life.
As Mehta points out, adoption is not a one-time event—it's an ongoing process of deepening engagement.
Here are the key interventions during this phase:
1. Usage Monitoring
You need clear visibility into how customers are actually using what you offer. At minimum, track:
Frequency of engagement
Feature or service adoption
Goal completion rates
Overall engagement levels
For early-stage companies, this doesn't need to be sophisticated. Simple tracking methods or even manual check-ins for your biggest customers is better than nothing.
The key is having an early warning system for when engagement drops.
2. The Health Score
This is where you translate usage data into meaningful insight. A health score is a single number that represents the overall strength of a customer relationship.
The basic formula is:
Customer Health = Usage Metrics + Success Metrics + Sentiment Metrics
Usage metrics reflect how actively they're using your offering
Success metrics track their progress toward desired outcomes
Sentiment metrics measure how they feel about the relationship
For startups, start simple. Rate each customer Red/Yellow/Green based on whatever data you have access to, even if it's just gut feel. As you grow, you can develop more sophisticated scoring.
3. The Regular Cadence
Establish a consistent rhythm of customer touchpoints based on their value and stage:
High-value customers: Bi-weekly or monthly calls
Mid-value customers: Monthly or quarterly reviews
Low-value customers: Quarterly check-ins or automated engagement
These aren't sales calls—they're strategic reviews focused on:
Progress toward defined goals
Obstacles that need addressing
New opportunities for value creation
One of the most successful early-stage founders I know does these calls personally for all customers above a certain threshold. It's time-intensive, but the retention impact is massive.
4. The Education Engine
Customers who deeply understand your offering are significantly less likely to leave.
Create a systematic approach to ongoing education:
Webinars or videos demonstrating advanced features or use cases
Knowledge resources solving common problems
User community where customers can learn from each other
Regular update communications
The goal isn't to overwhelm them with information, but to steadily expand their capability and confidence with what you provide.
Phase 3: Growth — The Expansion Opportunity
Once a customer is successfully onboarded and actively engaged, you've earned the right to explore growth opportunities.
There's a critical insight here that most founders miss:
Expansion isn't about selling more. It's about solving more problems.
When approached correctly, expansion feels like a natural extension of the value you're already delivering—not a sales pitch.
Here are the key interventions during this phase:
1. The Quarterly Business Review (QBR)
Even if you're early-stage, implementing a simplified version of the QBR can dramatically increase your expansion revenue.
The basic QBR structure:
Review of progress toward defined goals
Quantified value delivered to date
Strategic discussion of evolving needs
Introduction of relevant new capabilities
The magic of a well-run QBR is that expansion opportunities emerge organically from the conversation, rather than feeling forced.
2. The Executive Alignment
As your customer sees success with your offering, strategically expand your relationships within their organization—particularly upward.
This isn't about going around your champion. It's about giving them visibility by:
Sending executive summaries they can forward upward
Offering to join calls with their leadership
Creating case studies featuring their success
Inviting senior stakeholders to exclusive events
The broader and deeper your relationships, the more resilient the partnership becomes.
3. The Success Story
When a customer achieves significant results, document it meticulously and make them the hero of the story.
This serves multiple purposes:
It cements their sense of achievement
It creates internal advocates for what you offer
It gives you powerful social proof for new customers
It opens doors to expansion conversations
For early-stage companies especially, these success stories become invaluable assets for your entire growth strategy.
Implementing This Playbook When You're Just Starting Out
If you're an early-stage founder reading this, you might be thinking: "This sounds great, but I don't have a customer success team. It's just me and maybe a couple other people."
That's completely understandable. The good news is that customer success isn't about team size—it's about mindset and process.
Here's how to implement this playbook with limited resources:
1. Start with the highest-impact touch points
You don't need to implement everything at once. Focus on:
The welcome call (immediate impact on retention)
The success plan (clarity prevents future problems)
Basic usage monitoring (early warning system)
Quarterly business reviews (expansion opportunities)
2. Use technology as a force multiplier
You don't need fancy tools. Use:
Calendar reminders for key touchpoints
Email templates for consistent communication
Google Docs for success plans
Spreadsheets for tracking health scores
3. Build customer success into your core offering
The best customer success happens within the experience itself:
Clear getting-started processes
Progress indicators
Accessible education
Value-achievement celebrations
4. Make it everyone's job
In the early days, customer success isn't a department—it's a company-wide responsibility:
Your entire team needs to understand customer challenges
Everyone needs to know what successful customers look like
Sales needs to set the right expectations upfront
One founder I worked with had a brilliant approach: every Friday, the entire team spent one hour reviewing the progress of new customers. This built a company-wide obsession with customer outcomes that drove their exceptional retention.
The Hidden Benefit of Customer Success: Founder Sanity
There's one last aspect of customer success that rarely gets discussed, but I've seen it transform the lives of countless founders.
When your business reliably delivers outcomes that customers value, everything else becomes easier:
Sales cycles shorten because your reputation precedes you
Pricing pressure decreases because your value is evident
Recruiting improves because people want to join successful teams
Fundraising gets easier because the metrics investors care about improve
But beyond these business benefits, there's a personal one:
You sleep better at night.
The psychological weight of customer churn is enormous. The constant anxiety of "will they stay?" creates a background stress that affects every aspect of your life.
Building effective customer success processes doesn't just protect your revenue—it protects your mental health.
The Ultimate Customer Success Truth
Let me leave you with the most important insight from Mehta's work—one that's transformed how I think about business:
The companies that win in the long run aren't those with the best products or the best marketing. They're the ones whose customers succeed the most.
That's it. That's the whole game.
If your customers are consistently achieving their desired outcomes through what you offer, everything else takes care of itself.
So as you build your company, remember:
New customers are wonderful. But successful customers are invaluable.
Thank you for reading,
– Scott