The Influencer Marketing Reality Check
dailyblog.scottdclary.com
Hi All,
Here’s my daily newsletter navigating the crossroads of business, growth, and life.
If you love this content (please share it), but also…
Start here > https://stan.store/scottdclary
Check out my Podcast, connect with me on YouTube / Twitter, and read my Weekly newsletter.
Sponsor: FreshBooks
The numbers speak for themselves - over 30 million people have chosen FreshBooks, processing more than $60 billion in invoices and saving an incredible 192 hours annually on accounting tasks. As an all-in-one accounting solution, FreshBooks helps entrepreneurs and freelancers create professional estimates, track time, automatically bill clients, and capture expenses on the go - all while integrating seamlessly with over 100 business tools and providing award-winning customer service.
Ready to stop drowning in receipts and chasing payments? Start your 30-day free trial at freshbooks.com - no credit card required.
Plus, if you act before January 7th, get an exclusive Success Story listener offer of 75% off your first three months at freshbooks.com/pricing-offer.
Transform Your Business with FreshBooks
The New Reality of Influence
Every morning, another marketing team sits down to plan their influencer strategy. They pull up spreadsheets of follower counts, scroll through endless feeds of perfectly curated content, and try to figure out why their last three campaigns delivered plenty of likes but zero actual business impact.
Here's what nobody tells you about influencer marketing: Most brands are solving the wrong problem entirely.
Think about your last influencer campaign. You probably:
Looked for creators with big followings in your space
Negotiated rates based on audience size
Created detailed content briefs
Tracked likes, comments, and shares
Wondered why the sales didn't follow
Why is that?
Here's what's really happening in influence right now: While most brands compete for attention from traditional influencers, the most impactful partnerships are often happening in more focused spaces. Developer advocates on GitHub, medical professionals sharing research-backed advice, subject matter experts solving real problems in industry forums - these are the people driving actual decisions in their communities.
The pattern is clear: Real influence doesn't come from someone with a large audience talking about your product. It comes from being legitimately useful to the right community at the right time.
But here's what makes this shift so interesting: The brands that get this right aren't just saving money or generating better returns. They're building something their competitors can't copy - genuine authority within the communities that matter to their business.
The New Reality of Influence
Let's talk about what actually creates influence in 2024. Because it's not what most marketers think, and it's definitely not what most agencies are selling.
Think about the last time you made a significant purchase. Not a random impulse buy, but something that really mattered to you. Maybe it was a piece of software for your business, or a solution to a persistent problem. Who influenced that decision?
Chances are, it wasn't someone with a huge following. It was probably someone who:
Actually understood your specific problem
Had real experience solving it
Wasn't obviously trying to sell you anything
This is where real influence lives now. Not in carefully curated feeds or polished promotional posts, but in the trenches where real problems get solved.
Here's what this looks like in practice: A cybersecurity company recently shared that their biggest source of qualified leads isn't coming from industry influencers or thought leaders. It's coming from the security researchers who regularly contribute to vulnerability databases and help others fix actual security issues.
These researchers aren't influencers in any traditional sense. Most have modest followings. Many barely maintain a social media presence. But when they recommend a solution, their word carries more weight than a thousand promotional posts.
The math is simple but profound: A recommendation from someone who has earned real trust within a specific community will always outperform manufactured influence, no matter how wide that influence reaches.
But here's what makes this shift so fascinating: While most brands try to buy their way into conversations, the smartest ones are focusing on enabling the people who are already having them.
Think about what this means for your market:
Who are the people actually solving problems in your space?
Where are the real conversations happening?
What communities actually drive decisions?
The answers to these questions are worth more than any influencer database or engagement metric. Because they point to something far more valuable than influence: actual authority.
This changes everything about how we approach influence marketing. Instead of asking "How can we get influencers to promote us?" smart brands are asking "How can we support the people who are already helping our target audience?"
The difference isn't just semantic. It's the gap between renting attention and earning trust.
Making Real Influence Work
Let me show you exactly how the smartest brands are putting this into practice. Because understanding the shift is one thing - actually capitalizing on it is another entirely.
Remember that software company I mentioned earlier? Here's what they actually did: Instead of reaching out to tech influencers, they started monitoring developer forums and open source projects. They looked for people who were consistently helping others solve problems related to their product category.
They found three types of people:
The problem solvers who always seemed to have the right answer
The teachers who broke down complex concepts for others
The innovators who were building interesting solutions
But here's where they got clever. Instead of sending these people a standard influencer brief, they approached them with something different entirely: "We notice you're already helping people solve X problem. How can we help you do that better?"
The results surprised even them. Not only did these partnerships cost far less than traditional influencer campaigns, but they also generated leads that converted at 5x their normal rate.
Think about what they were really doing here. Instead of trying to insert their brand into existing conversations, they were enabling the people who were already trusted within those conversations.
This works across industries, but it requires a completely different playbook:
First, forget everything you know about influencer outreach. The goal isn't to find people who can promote your product - it's to find people who are already solving problems your product relates to.
Then, flip the typical partnership model on its head. Instead of telling these experts what to say about your product, ask them what they need to better serve their community. The best partnerships often start with "How can we help?" rather than "Here's what we want you to do."
Here's what this looks like in the real world: A fitness brand discovered their best partners weren't fitness influencers at all - they were physical therapists and trainers who spent their days solving real mobility problems. By giving these professionals early access to products and genuine input on development, they built a network of authentic advocates who drove more sales than all their traditional influencer campaigns combined.
The key isn't the tactic - it's the mindset shift. You're not looking for people to promote your product. You're looking for people who are already doing important work in your space and figuring out how to support them.
This changes everything about how you measure success. Instead of tracking reach and engagement, you start tracking:
How many real problems get solved
What kind of questions your partners get asked
How conversations about your product category evolve
The goal isn't to make a splash - it's to become an integral part of the solution ecosystem in your space.
Measuring What Actually Works
Let's talk about measuring success. Because if you're tracking the wrong metrics, you'll optimize for the wrong results - no matter how good your strategy is.
Here's a perfect example: A B2B software company was celebrating their "most successful" influencer campaign ever. Their metrics looked amazing - reach was up 300%, engagement had never been higher. But their sales team was telling a different story entirely.
When they dug into their actual sales data, they discovered something fascinating: Their highest-converting partner wasn't an influencer at all. It was a software architect who regularly shared detailed solution blueprints with his modest but highly engaged following.
This reveals something crucial about measuring influence: The metrics that look good in reports often have zero correlation with the results that actually matter to your business.
Think about it this way. When you're buying something important, do you care:
How many followers recommended it?
How many likes their post got?
How polished their content was?
Or do you care about:
Whether they actually understand your problem
If they've solved it before
What specific results they achieved
This is where most measurement goes wrong. We track what's easy to measure instead of what actually matters.
Here's how the smartest brands are measuring real influence:
Instead of tracking post reach, they track solution adoption. How many people actually implemented the approach their partner recommended? What results did they get?
Instead of counting comments, they analyze conversation depth. Are people asking detailed questions? Sharing specific challenges? Actually engaging with the solution?
But here's what's really interesting: When you measure the right things, you naturally start doing the right things. Your partnerships become more focused. Your content gets more specific. Your results get better.
Let me show you what this looks like in practice: The most meaningful metrics for measuring influence aren't about reach or engagement. They're about actual impact on your bottom line:
How many customer problems get solved by your partners (and lead to sales): Track this through UTM codes on partner content, custom discount codes, or dedicated landing pages for each partner
How many times prospects mention your partners during buying conversations: Set up simple partner attribution fields in your CRM and train your sales team to ask "where did you hear about us?"
How often your partners' content directly influences purchase decisions: Use post-purchase surveys, add partner names to your "How did you hear about us?" forms, and track partner-specific referral links
The tools to track this are simpler than you think:
Google Analytics for tracking partner-specific traffic and conversion paths
Custom URL parameters to trace content performance
Basic CRM fields to log influence touchpoints
Simple post-purchase surveys using tools like Typeform
Attribution platforms like Branch or AppsFlyer if you need deeper insights
These metrics matter because they connect real expertise to actual revenue, not just vanity metrics. When you focus on tracking how influence drives sales, you start to see which partnerships truly matter to your business.
The lesson is clear: Real influence doesn't scale like traditional metrics. It grows through actual impact on revenue, not artificial amplification. And by setting up these basic tracking systems, you can prove it.
This changes everything about how you approach partnerships:
Instead of asking for post frequency, you're looking at:
Number of customer questions answered each week in relevant forums
Quality of solutions provided (measured through customer feedback)
Direct sales inquiries generated from their helpful content
Instead of measuring audience size, you're tracking:
Percentage of their audience that matches your buyer persona
How many qualified leads come from their referrals
Which specific customer segments they influence
Instead of tracking generic engagement, you measure:
Conversion rates from their referral links
How often their recommendations lead to demos or trials
Average deal size from their referred customers
The future belongs to brands that understand this shift. Not because they're better at influencer marketing, but because they've stopped doing influencer marketing entirely. They're building expertise networks instead.
Scott