The 'Successful' Business Partner Who Bankrupted My Company
dailyblog.scottdclary.com
Hi All,
Here’s my daily newsletter navigating the crossroads of business, growth, and life.
If you love this content (please share it), but also…
Start here > https://stan.store/scottdclary
Check out my Podcast, connect with me on YouTube / Twitter, and read my Weekly newsletter.
Sponsor: FreshBooks
The numbers speak for themselves - over 30 million people have chosen FreshBooks, processing more than $60 billion in invoices and saving an incredible 192 hours annually on accounting tasks. As an all-in-one accounting solution, FreshBooks helps entrepreneurs and freelancers create professional estimates, track time, automatically bill clients, and capture expenses on the go - all while integrating seamlessly with over 100 business tools and providing award-winning customer service.
Ready to stop drowning in receipts and chasing payments? Start your 30-day free trial at freshbooks.com - no credit card required.
Plus, if you act before January 7th, get an exclusive Success Story listener offer of 75% off your first three months at freshbooks.com/pricing-offer.
Transform Your Business with FreshBooks
I've Picked Tons of Bad Business Partners (So You Don't Have To)
I lost $200,000 because I trusted someone's past success to predict their future performance.
The painful part? On paper, everything checked out. They had legitimate exits. Real track records. When we started working together, they even proved they could sell – bringing in customer after customer with impressive efficiency.
The problem? They couldn't deliver what they were promising.
I watched in horror as the gap between sales and fulfillment grew wider and wider. Eventually, I found myself dipping into my own savings to refund customers, trying to salvage what was left of my reputation while my partner had long stopped responding to calls.
That's when I realized: past exits don't predict future execution. The ability to sell doesn't equal the ability to deliver. And most dangerously – someone can be great at building and selling companies without being good at actually running them.
In the next few minutes, I'm going to break down:
Why past success can be misleading
The critical difference between selling ability and execution ability
How to spot partners who can both acquire AND serve customers
The questions I now ask that would have saved me $200,000
But first, you need to understand something crucial... there's a massive difference between being good at doing deals and being good at delivering value.
The Exit Illusion
Here's what nobody tells you about successful exits: they're often more about timing and narrative than operational excellence. I've now watched dozens of founders sell companies at impressive valuations, only to see their next ventures implode because they never actually built the systems and capabilities that create sustainable value.
Think about it like this: someone can be brilliant at spotting opportunities, raising money, and closing deals. They can even be great at getting customers in the door. But none of that matters if they can't build the machine that keeps those customers happy.
I learned this lesson the expensive way. My partner was a master at painting the vision. They could walk into a room and walk out with signed contracts. What they couldn't do was build the operational backbone to fulfill those contracts.
The Hidden Cost of Sales-First Partners
When you partner with someone who's all sales and no delivery, something dangerous happens. At first, it feels amazing – money is flowing in, customers are signing up, momentum is building. Your partner looks like a genius.
Then reality hits.
The promises start coming due. The customers start asking questions. The support tickets pile up. And suddenly, you realize you're carrying the entire weight of delivery on your shoulders while your partner is still out there selling, making promises you'll have to keep.
That's exactly what happened to me. By month three, I was working 80-hour weeks trying to deliver on promises I hadn't even been part of making. By month six, I was refunding customers out of my own pocket. And by month nine? My partner had moved on to their next venture while I was still cleaning up the mess.
The Three Types of Business Partners
Through painful experience, I've learned there are three types of business partners, and understanding the difference is crucial:
The Dealmakers are fantastic at negotiations, raising money, and closing sales. They make everything look easy. But they often lack the patience or interest in building sustainable operations.
The Builders excel at creating systems, managing teams, and delivering consistent value. They're not always flashy, but they create lasting value through execution.
The rare Integrators can do both. They understand that sales without delivery is just creating future problems, and they know how to balance growth with operational excellence.
My biggest mistake? I kept falling for Dealmakers while thinking I'd found Integrators.
The Partnership Problem No One Talks About
Here's the worst part about modern business culture.
We've created a system that often rewards the appearance of success over the reality of value creation.
The Real Questions No One Asks
When I look back at my due diligence, I realize I asked all the wrong questions. I checked references. I verified past exits. I even talked to former employees. But I never asked the questions that would have revealed the true red flags.
Here are the questions I should have asked:
"Can you walk me through, in detail, how you handled your last major operational crisis?"
"What systems did you personally build in your last company?"
"Show me an example of a process you created that kept running after you left."
But more importantly, I should have watched instead of just asked. Because people will tell you who they are if you pay attention.
The Behavioral Red Flags I Missed
Looking back, the warning signs were screaming at me:
My partner got visibly uncomfortable when we discussed operational details. They'd quickly shift conversations back to sales targets and growth plans. At the time, I interpreted this as "staying focused on the big picture." Now I recognize it as avoidance.
They were brilliant at describing solutions but vague about implementation. Every operational challenge was met with "we'll figure it out" or "we'll hire for that." What I heard was optimism. What I should have heard was lack of experience.
The Partnership Paradox
Here's what makes this so tricky: the traits that make someone an excellent closer often make them a terrible builder. The very characteristics that help them sell – optimism, future focus, quick decisions – can become liabilities when it's time to deliver.
Think about it. The ability to see only possibilities and ignore potential problems? Great for sales. Terrible for operations.
The confidence to make promises and figure out delivery later? Fantastic for closing deals. Disastrous for building sustainable businesses.
What Actually Works
After my expensive education in partnership failures, I've developed a system that's saved me from making the same mistake again. I call it the "Show Don't Tell" Partnership Test.
The core principle is simple: never partner based on what someone says they can do. Partner based on what you've seen them actually do.
This means running small test projects before any formal partnership. It means watching how they handle minor problems before trusting them with major ones. Most importantly, it means verifying their operational capabilities firsthand.
The "Show Don't Tell" Framework
The best partnerships I've seen didn't start with contracts or equity splits. They started with shared work. Here's how I structure partnership trials now:
Start with a single project that touches every aspect of the business you'll run together. Make it small enough to fail safely, but complex enough to reveal how someone really operates.
Watch carefully for these critical indicators:
Their response to unexpected problems reveals more about their capabilities than any success story. Do they dive in to help solve issues, or do they just escalate to you?
The way they handle customer complaints tells you everything about their operational mindset. Are they focused on quick fixes, or do they build systems to prevent future issues?
The Three-Month Test
I've learned that three months is the magic number for really understanding a potential partner. Here's why:
In month one, everyone's on their best behavior. You'll see their highlight reel – how they want to be perceived.
By month two, real challenges start emerging. You'll see their actual work patterns and how they handle stress.
In month three, their true operational capabilities become clear. The gap between what they promised and what they can deliver starts showing up.
The Partnership Foundation
If someone passes the three-month test, there's still work to do before formalizing anything. I now require crystal clear alignment on these fundamental areas:
Operational Responsibilities Not just who does what, but who has the final say in different areas. I learned the hard way that overlapping authority is a recipe for disaster.
Success Metrics Beyond revenue targets, we need shared definitions of what good execution looks like. Are we measuring the same things? Do we value the same outcomes?
Problem Resolution Every partnership faces challenges. Having an agreed-upon framework for resolving conflicts before they arise is crucial.
The Final Test
Before signing any partnership agreement, I now ask potential partners to do something that's revealed more than any test project or reference check:
I ask them to write out, in detail, how they plan to handle their operational responsibilities for the first six months.
The responses are telling:
Dealmakers give vague answers focused on growth targets. Builders provide detailed plans with specific milestones. Integrators show both vision and practical steps to achieve it.
The Hard Truth About Choosing Partners
Looking back at my $200,000 mistake, the most painful part wasn't losing the money. It was realizing that I could have prevented it all by simply trusting what I saw instead of what I hoped to see.
The reality is that great business partners aren't found through quick conversations over coffee or impressive pitch decks. They're revealed through shared challenges, operational stress, and the unglamorous work of actually building something together.
These days, I have a simple rule: No partnership discussions until we've worked together in the trenches.
This isn't about being untrusting. It's about being realistic. Because the truth is, someone can be a genuinely good person and still be a terrible business partner. They can have impressive exits and still not be right for your business.
What matters isn't their past success, but their ability to create value right now, with you, in this specific context.
Because here's the counterintuitive truth I've learned. The harder you make it to become your partner, the better partners you'll attract.
Strong operators respect thorough vetting. They want to prove themselves through action. They understand that real partnerships are earned, not negotiated.
The ones who push for quick commitments? Who resist detailed operational discussions? Who want to focus on the "big picture" while avoiding the details? They're telling you exactly who they are.
Listen to them.
Your Next Move
If you're considering a business partnership right now, I want you to pause and ask yourself:
Have I seen this person actually operate, or am I being seduced by their ability to sell?
Do I know how they handle real problems, or am I just impressed by their past successes?
Am I rushing into this partnership out of excitement or fear?
Because here's what I know now: The right partners are worth waiting for. The right partners want to prove themselves through action. The right partners understand that trust is earned through consistent execution, not promised through impressive presentations.
The most expensive partnerships are the ones you rush into. The most valuable ones are those you build carefully, deliberately, and with clear eyes about what you're both bringing to the table.
Don't make my $200,000 mistake. Take the time to see who someone really is before you bet your business on them.
Your future self will thank you.
Scott