The Truth About Business Masterminds (And What to Join Instead)
dailyblog.scottdclary.com
Hi All,
Here’s my daily newsletter navigating the crossroads of business, growth, and life.
If you love this content (please share it), but also…
Start here > https://newsletter.scottdclary.com
Check out my Podcast, connect with me on YouTube / Twitter, and read my Weekly newsletter.
Sponsor: Lingoda
Look, I'll be real with you, my French used to be solid. I learned it in school. But when I booked a trip to France a few years ago, it was a total blank. I could barely order a croissant.
So I joined the Lingoda Sprint Challenge. And it changed everything. Live classes, five students max, real teachers. In two months, I went from bonjour to café conversations.
Here's how it works - you take 30 or 60 classes in 60 days, and when you finish, you get 50% of your money back. That works out to about $4.50 per class, which is honestly amazing for live instruction.
Go to try.lingoda.com/success_sprint, use code SCOTT.SPRINT for extra €20 off.
Listen Here:
The Truth About Business Masterminds (And What to Join Instead)
You just dropped $25,000 to sit in a room with "like-minded entrepreneurs."
The sales page promised transformation. Exclusive access. A trusted inner circle that would catapult your business to the next level.
Six months later, you've got a lighter bank account, a handful of business cards you'll never use, and that familiar sinking feeling that you've been sold a dream that never materialized.
The business mastermind industrial complex is one of the most brilliant—and insidious—business models ever created.
It leverages your deepest desires as an entrepreneur: connection in a lonely journey, validation of your potential, and shortcuts to success you haven't yet achieved.
I know because I've been on both sides. I've paid five figures to join masterminds that changed nothing. I've also built communities that genuinely transformed businesses and lives.
The difference isn't in the price tag or the promise. It's in the structure, incentives, and expectations.
Let me pull back the curtain on what really happens in most business masterminds, why they fail to deliver, and what you should invest in instead.
The Mastermind Mirage
Most business masterminds operate on a simple but powerful promise:
"Join this exclusive group, and you'll shortcut years of struggle by accessing the collective wisdom of successful peers."
It's an intoxicating proposition for the ambitious but isolated entrepreneur. Who wouldn't want to bypass painful trial and error?
The reality is far less magical.
In typical masterminds, you'll find:
Uneven value exchange – A room where 80% give and 20% take, creating a one-sided dynamic where the same people always contribute while others perpetually consume
Success theater – Members sharing highlight reels while hiding the messy truth of their businesses, creating an echo chamber of exaggerated achievements
The blind leading the blind – Entrepreneurs at similar stages giving each other advice based on limited experience, resulting in the spread of untested theories rather than proven strategies
Artificial intimacy – Surface-level vulnerability confused for genuine connection, with everyone playing the role they think they should rather than showing up authentically
The most telling sign? Almost no one can point to specific, measurable outcomes from their mastermind investments.
Instead, they cite vague benefits like "amazing connections" or "inspiring conversations"—the business equivalent of paying for therapy but never doing the work between sessions.
But what makes these groups so seductive, and why do smart, successful people keep joining them?
The Psychology Behind the Mastermind Addiction
To understand why masterminds persist despite their poor ROI, we need to look at the powerful psychological drivers at play.
Let's examine the hidden forces that keep entrepreneurs throwing good money after bad:
1. The Validation Vortex
Entrepreneurship is riddled with self-doubt. Masterminds offer temporary relief through external validation.
When you're in a room where everyone nods at your ideas and tells you you're "just a few tweaks away from a breakthrough," it creates a dopamine hit that feels like progress—even when nothing has actually changed in your business.
2. The Proximity Illusion
We've been conditioned to believe that proximity to success leads to success.
It's why people pay thousands to attend conferences where they'll briefly breathe the same air as their heroes. Masterminds capitalize on this by promising access to people "just ahead of you" on the journey.
The problem? Proximity without implementation is just expensive spectating.
3. The Commitment Bias
Once you've invested significant money in a mastermind, your brain works overtime to justify that decision.
You'll ignore red flags, rationalize poor experiences, and even sign up for another year—not because of results, but because admitting it was a bad investment feels worse than doubling down.
4. The Exclusivity Effect
The harder something is to access, the more we value it—regardless of its actual utility.
Masterminds with application processes, high price points, and "limited spots" trigger our desire to be in select company. We confuse the exclusivity of the group with the value of its content.
Now that we understand why these programs maintain their allure despite underwhelming results, let's look at the people running them and why their incentives rarely align with your success.
The Mastermind Business Model: Follow the Money
Behind every mastermind is a business model designed to maximize profit while minimizing accountability.
The economics reveal why most deliver far less than they promise:
The typical high-ticket mastermind charges $25,000-$50,000 annually from 20-50 members. That's $500,000 to $2.5 million in predictable revenue with remarkably low delivery costs.
Think about it:
Minimal overhead – A few retreat weekends at boutique hotels, some Zoom calls, and perhaps a Slack channel. The actual delivery cost is often less than 10% of revenue.
Scalable structure – The work to run a 20-person mastermind is nearly identical to running a 40-person one, but the revenue doubles.
Renewal focus – The business model depends on members renewing, not on those members seeing tangible results. This creates a perverse incentive to foster dependency rather than transformation.
Self-selecting members – Those most likely to join are often those least equipped to critically evaluate the return on investment, creating a perfect customer acquisition loop.
The ugly truth? Many mastermind leaders make more money from their groups than they ever made in the businesses they supposedly succeeded in.
They've found it far more profitable to teach entrepreneurship than to practice it.
But not all community models are flawed. Let's examine what actually works, and what you should look for instead of the traditional mastermind structure.
The Alternative: Results-Driven Learning Communities
The problem isn't group learning or peer support. Those are valuable tools for growth when structured correctly.
The problem is the incentive misalignment and accountability vacuum in typical masterminds.
Here's what to look for instead:
1. Results-Based Refunds
The single most important filter: Does the group offer meaningful refunds based on results, not just satisfaction?
When a leader puts their money where their mouth is, everything changes. Suddenly, they're incentivized to ensure you implement and succeed, not just feel good about the experience.
2. Verifiable Success Stories
Don't just read testimonials on a sales page. Ask to speak directly with current and former members.
The questions to ask:
"What specific, measurable outcome did you achieve directly because of this group?"
"What was the approximate ROI on your investment?"
"What specific advice did you implement that you wouldn't have discovered elsewhere?"
If answers are vague or purely emotional, run.
3. Structured Implementation Systems
True transformation comes from implementation, not information.
Look for communities with clear frameworks for turning advice into action:
Accountability mechanisms that have actual consequences
Documentation requirements for progress
Regular review cycles with objective measurement
4. Complementary Expertise
The best communities bring together people with different but complementary skills and experiences.
A room full of marketers will give you marketing advice. A room with a marketer, an operations expert, a finance professional, and a leadership coach will give you a business transformation.
Let's now look at how you can evaluate whether any group is worth joining, regardless of what it calls itself.
The Due Diligence Checklist: Evaluating Any Learning Community
Before you write another check for a mastermind or community, run it through this evaluation framework:
1. The Leader's Business Model
Ask yourself: Does this person make more money from teaching/coaching than from actual business success?
If someone's primary income is from teaching entrepreneurship rather than practicing it, proceed with extreme caution. The best advice usually comes from those still in the arena.
2. The Member Selection Process
How carefully are members vetted? A rigorous selection process focused on fit, contribution potential, and implementation capability—not just ability to pay—is essential for a valuable community.
3. The Feedback Mechanisms
What systems exist to measure and improve the community's impact? Groups committed to results have formal processes for tracking member outcomes and evolving their approach based on what actually works.
4. The Exit Interviews
What do former members say—especially those who didn't renew? Ask the leader for introductions to members who left. Their perspective will tell you more than any sales page ever could.
5. The Implementation Rate
What percentage of advice given in the community actually gets implemented? In effective groups, this number is tracked and typically exceeds 60%. In typical masterminds, it's below 20%.
Now that you know what to look for in external communities, let's discuss the most overlooked alternative: building your own.
The DIY Solution: Creating Your Own Circle of Trust
The most valuable learning community might be one you create yourself.
The best masterminds aren't sold—they're built.
Here's how to construct your own high-impact circle:
1. Start Small and Specific
Begin with just 3-5 people who share similar ambitions but bring diverse skills. The group should be small enough for deep connection but diverse enough for valuable perspective.
2. Set Clear Parameters
Meeting frequency and duration
Confidentiality boundaries
Commitment expectations
Progress documentation requirements
3. Implement a Formal Structure
Even among friends, structure matters. Create a simple format:
Updates (what's happened since last meeting)
Challenges (current obstacles requiring input)
Commitments (specific actions each member will take before next meeting)
Accountability review (did everyone do what they promised last time?)
4. Focus on Implementation
The group's success metric shouldn't be how good the conversations are, but how much each member actually implements from the group's input.
Track this rigorously. Call out patterns of non-implementation.
5. Regularly Reassess Value
Every quarter, have each member anonymously rate the value they're receiving and giving. Use this data to evolve the group's structure and potentially its membership.
I've seen DIY masterminds deliver 10x more value than $50,000 programs because the incentives are perfectly aligned: everyone's sole focus is on helping each other succeed, not on selling the next program.
The Uncomfortable Truth About What You Really Need
After analyzing hundreds of entrepreneurs' experiences with masterminds and communities, I've reached an uncomfortable conclusion about what actually drives business success.
You don't need more advice. You need implementation accountability.
Most entrepreneurs already know what they should be doing. They don't lack information—they lack the discipline to consistently execute on what they already know.
The best community isn't one that gives you new ideas. It's one that forces you to implement the ideas you already have.
This is why groups with strong accountability mechanisms consistently outperform those focused on "masterminding" new strategies. Implementation beats ideation every time.
The next time you're tempted by a mastermind program, ask yourself:
"Do I need new strategies, or do I need to finally implement the ones I already know would work?"
For most, the honest answer is the latter.
Making Your Decision: The Path Forward
You now understand why most masterminds fail to deliver value, what alternatives actually work, and how to evaluate any community before joining.
The question is: what will you do with this information?
If you're currently in a mastermind, have the courage to objectively assess its impact on your business. Not how it makes you feel, but what it has measurably helped you achieve.
If you're considering joining one, apply the due diligence framework I've outlined. Demand specificity about outcomes, not vague promises about transformation.
And if you're feeling isolated in your entrepreneurial journey, consider the DIY approach. Five committed peers with the right structure can deliver more value than the most expensive mastermind in the world.
Remember, the goal isn't to find people who make you feel good about your potential. It's to find people who help you actually fulfill it through consistent, focused action.
The mastermind that transforms your business isn't the one with the cleverest marketing or the highest price tag.
It's the one that turns advice into implementation, potential into results, and conversations into conversions.
Everything else is just expensive networking.
Thank you for reading.
– Scott