When to Hire a Salesperson (And When to Keep Selling Yourself)
dailyblog.scottdclary.com
Hi All,
Here’s my daily newsletter navigating the crossroads of business, growth, and life.
If you love this content (please share it), but also…
Start here > https://newsletter.scottdclary.com
Check out my Podcast, connect with me on YouTube / Twitter, and read my Weekly newsletter.
Sponsor: Lingoda
Look, I'll be real with you, my French used to be solid. I learned it in school. But when I booked a trip to France a few years ago, it was a total blank. I could barely order a croissant.
So I joined the Lingoda Sprint Challenge. And it changed everything. Live classes, five students max, real teachers. In two months, I went from bonjour to café conversations.
Here's how it works - you take 30 or 60 classes in 60 days, and when you finish, you get 50% of your money back. That works out to about $4.50 per class, which is honestly amazing for live instruction.
Go to try.lingoda.com/success_sprint, use code SCOTT.SPRINT for extra €20 off.
Listen Here:
When to Hire a Salesperson (And When to Keep Selling Yourself)
You're drowning in sales calls.
Your calendar is a minefield of demos, follow-ups, and "just checking in" meetings. Your inbox has become a never-ending stream of prospect questions. You're staying up late to send proposals after finally finding time to build your actual product.
Somewhere between "visionary founder" and "sales grunt," you lost your way.
So you think: I need to hire a salesperson. Now.
Not so fast.
Hiring a salesperson too early is one of the most expensive mistakes founders make. Bringing on the wrong sales hire—or the right hire at the wrong time—can burn through your runway, confuse your market positioning, and leave you worse off than when you started.
But waiting too long can be just as costly. Every hour you spend selling is an hour you're not building, leading, or planning. Your growth flatlines because you've become the bottleneck.
I've watched founders on both sides of this decision. Some who hired sales teams prematurely and crashed their promising startups. Others who stubbornly refused to let go of sales until their companies stagnated.
Let me show you how to know exactly when to make this transition—and how to do it without derailing everything you've built.
The Founder-Seller Advantage
Before we dive into when to hire, let's be clear about something:
No one will ever sell your product as effectively as you can.
This isn't just founder ego talking. It's mathematics.
As the founder, you have unique advantages that no salesperson—no matter how experienced—can replicate:
You understand the product at a molecular level You know not just what it does, but why every feature exists. You can explain technical details that would make most salespeople break into a cold sweat.
You have ultimate authority to customize and commit When a prospect asks "Can it do X?" you can say "Not yet, but I'll prioritize that for you." And mean it. No salesperson can make those promises.
You embody the company's vision and story Customers aren't just buying a product—they're buying into a future you're creating. You are the most compelling storyteller for that vision.
You've felt the pain you're solving Most founders build solutions to problems they've experienced. That authentic understanding creates connection that's hard to fake.
Shopify's founder Tobi Lütke personally sold to their first 100 customers. Brian Chesky of Airbnb lived with hosts and personally helped them improve their listings. Sara Blakely sold Spanx trunk-to-trunk before landing her first major retail deal.
They weren't just selling—they were learning, iterating, and building relationships that would shape their companies for years to come.
So why would you ever hire a salesperson?
Because eventually, the math changes.
When Founder-Led Sales Breaks Down
Now let's look at the other side. Despite your natural advantages, there comes a point where personally handling sales becomes unsustainable.
Here are the warning signs that you're reaching that breaking point:
Your growth is capped by your calendar When you're turning down meetings or pushing them weeks out because you literally have no more hours in the day.
Product development is suffering When critical product decisions are delayed because you're stuck in sales mode.
You've become reactive instead of strategic When you're so deep in the sales trenches that you've lost sight of the bigger picture.
Your sales process has become predictable When you can describe exactly what happens at each stage, what objections arise, and how to handle them.
You're starting to resent sales conversations When the activities that once energized you now drain you.
This breaking point typically happens somewhere between $500K and $2M in annual revenue for most SaaS or service businesses. But revenue isn't the best indicator—your sales process maturity is.
The right time to hire a salesperson isn't when you can afford one. It's when you can train one.
Let me explain what that means and how to know if you're there yet.
The Sales Process Maturity Test
Before you even think about hiring, you need to know if your sales process is ready to be handed off. Here's how to find out:
1. Documentation
Can you answer these questions with specific documentation?
What's your ideal customer profile, in detail?
What specific pain points trigger purchase decisions?
What objections come up consistently, and how do you address them?
What's the step-by-step process from lead to close?
What are the conversion rates at each stage of your funnel?
If you're answering with "it depends" or "I just know it when I see it," your process isn't ready to be transferred to someone else.
2. Repeatability
Look at your last 10 closed deals:
Did they follow roughly the same path?
Were the sales cycles similar in length?
Did you use the same core messaging and materials?
Were pricing and terms relatively standard?
If every deal is a unique snowflake requiring founder intuition and custom work, you're not ready to hand off sales.
3. Economics
The brutal math check:
What's your average deal size?
What's your customer acquisition cost?
How long is your sales cycle?
What's your customer lifetime value?
A salesperson needs to generate at least 3-5x their fully loaded cost to make economic sense. For a $100K/year salesperson (salary + commission + benefits), that means generating $300-500K in annual revenue.
If your economics don't support this, you're not ready.
Now let's look at how to make this decision in practice by examining two founders who faced this crossroads.
Tale of Two Founders: Sarah vs. Michael
Sarah founded a marketing automation platform. By year two, she was doing $1.2M ARR with a small team of engineers. She was personally handling all sales calls—about 15-20 per week.
The sales process was straightforward: demo, proposal, technical review, close. Average deal size was $24K per year with an 80% renewal rate. Sales cycles averaged 45 days.
Sarah had documented her entire process, including common objections and their answers. She had clear customer profiles and could predict which prospects would convert with about 70% accuracy.
She was ready to hire a salesperson.
Michael founded a custom analytics solution for manufacturing companies. After 18 months, he was doing about $900K in services revenue with three technical implementation specialists.
Every sales conversation was different. Some prospects needed heavy customization discussions. Others required multiple stakeholder meetings. Sales cycles ranged from 3 weeks to 6 months.
Michael's value proposition was still evolving. He was constantly adjusting pricing and scope based on what he learned in sales conversations.
Michael wasn't ready to hire a salesperson.
The difference wasn't revenue—it was process maturity and predictability.
Sarah could train someone to follow her playbook because she had a playbook. Michael was still writing his.
Let's explore what happened next for both of them, and what we can learn from their experiences.
When Sarah Hired (And How She Did It Right)
When Sarah decided to hire her first salesperson, she didn't rush to post a job listing. Instead, she:
Shadowed first, sold second She hired someone with relevant B2B SaaS experience, but rather than throwing them straight into the deep end, she had them shadow her calls for a full month. The new hire didn't run a single demo until they could practically recite Sarah's pitch.
Created a "sales bible" Sarah documented everything: call scripts, email templates, objection handling, pricing guidelines, when to loop in technical resources—everything.
Started with inbound only The new salesperson only handled inbound leads that matched their ideal customer profile for the first three months. This created early wins and built confidence.
Set clear metrics beyond revenue Rather than just revenue targets, Sarah tracked activity metrics (calls, demos, proposals) and conversion rates at each stage. This helped identify exactly where coaching was needed.
Stayed involved in deals strategically Sarah joined calls at critical junctures—not to take over, but to observe and provide specific feedback.
The result? By month four, her salesperson was closing deals at 85% of Sarah's rate—acceptable given the founder advantage. By month six, they were fully ramped and Sarah had reclaimed 25 hours a week.
The key was that Sarah didn't hire to escape sales. She hired to scale what was already working.
Now let's see what happened when Michael tried to make the same move.
When Michael Hired (And Why It Failed)
Michael was drowning in sales conversations and product decisions. He needed help, so he hired an experienced enterprise salesperson from a major software company.
Here's where things went wrong:
Process gaps became chasms Without a documented process, the new hire created their own—one that didn't match Michael's intuitive approach. Prospects got confused by the inconsistent messaging.
Customization created chaos When customers asked for customizations, the salesperson either made promises Michael couldn't keep or missed opportunities by being too rigid.
Missing context led to misalignment The salesperson didn't understand the deeper "why" behind feature decisions or pricing structures, so they couldn't effectively articulate value.
Expensive learning Michael essentially paid someone $10K+ per month to learn things he already knew but hadn't documented.
After four months and zero closed deals, Michael let the salesperson go and went back to selling himself.
The problem wasn't the salesperson. It was the timing.
Michael needed to stabilize his product and process before handing off sales. He should have hired a sales coordinator to handle logistics while he continued to run demos and close deals.
Let's now explore the middle path that works for founders who aren't quite ready for a full sales hire but need to start scaling themselves.
The Middle Path: How to Scale Before You're Ready to Hire
If you're not ready for a full sales hire but you're drowning in sales activities, there's a smart middle path:
1. Hire a Sales Coordinator, Not a Salesperson
A sales coordinator can:
Manage your calendar and pipeline
Handle follow-up communications
Prepare proposals and contracts
Collect and organize customer feedback
Track metrics and create reports
This frees you from the administrative burden of sales while keeping you in the conversations that only you can have.
The best part? A coordinator costs 30-50% less than a full salesperson and doesn't require the same level of process maturity to be effective.
2. Productize Parts of Your Sales Process
Look for opportunities to replace live interaction with scalable alternatives:
Create detailed case studies that answer common questions
Build an interactive demo that prospects can explore on their own
Develop a diagnostic tool that helps prospects self-qualify
Record walkthrough videos that explain complex concepts
Notion did this brilliantly by creating templates and examples that demonstrated value before prospects ever talked to a human.
3. Create a Success Team First
Sometimes the bottleneck isn't in selling—it's in onboarding and supporting customers post-sale.
Hiring a customer success person before a salesperson can:
Free up your time from post-sale activities
Improve retention (reducing pressure to acquire new customers)
Generate valuable feedback to improve your product and sales process
Now that we've explored the middle path, let's talk about what to look for when you are ready to make that first sales hire.
When You're Ready: How to Hire Your First Salesperson
When your process is mature enough and you're ready to pull the trigger, here's how to find the right first sales hire:
1. Fit Your Stage, Not Your Vision
Don't hire for where you want to be. Hire for where you are.
If you're selling to SMBs with a $5K ACV, don't hire someone from Salesforce who's used to 7-figure enterprise deals. They won't have the right skills or expectations.
Look for someone who has:
Sold to your exact customer profile
Handled similar deal sizes and sales cycles
Worked in an environment similar to yours (not just big-company experience)
2. Hunger Over Polish
Your first sales hire needs to be willing to:
Figure things out with minimal direction
Handle rejection and uncertainty
Do unglamorous work (like data entry and follow-ups)
Learn continuously and adapt quickly
This often means hiring someone earlier in their career who's looking to prove themselves, not a veteran who expects a polished machine.
3. Test Before You Commit
Before making a full hire, consider:
Paid working interviews (have them run a real demo)
Role-playing scenarios with common objections
Contract-to-hire arrangements for 90 days
Asking them to document how they'd approach the role
Stripe famously had candidates work on real projects for two days before extending offers. This revealed more than any interview could.
Now, let's talk about how to set up your first sales hire for success once they're on board.
Setting Your First Sales Hire Up for Success
Even the perfect hire will fail without the right support. Here's how to create conditions for success:
1. Expectation Management
Be crystal clear about:
Ramp time (typically 3-6 months for full productivity)
Activity metrics vs. outcome metrics
What good looks like at 30, 60, and 90 days
When and how you'll be involved in deals
Misaligned expectations are the number one reason sales hires fail at startups.
2. Knowledge Transfer
Create a structured onboarding that includes:
Shadowing your sales calls (at least 10-15)
In-depth product training
Customer interviews to understand pain points firsthand
Competitor analysis and positioning
This isn't something you do once and forget. Knowledge transfer should be ongoing, with regular check-ins.
3. Tools and Resources
Provide the infrastructure for success:
CRM properly set up with your sales process
Email templates and sequences
Call scripts and battlecards
Case studies and social proof
Demo environments and materials
Don't make them create these from scratch while also trying to sell.
4. Feedback Loops
Establish regular reviews of:
Recorded calls (with permission)
Won and lost deal analysis
Pipeline reviews focused on strategy, not just numbers
Customer feedback post-purchase
The goal is continuous improvement, not just performance management.
Final Thoughts: The Founder's Evolution
The hardest part of this transition isn't the hiring—it's the identity shift.
Many founders struggle to let go of sales because it feels like surrendering control of their company's destiny. Every interaction with a customer is a chance to learn, adjust, and improve. Handing that off feels risky.
But here's the truth: Your job isn't to sell your product forever. It's to build a company that can sell your product without you.
This doesn't mean becoming detached. The best founders maintain customer connection even as they scale:
Marc Benioff still meets with Salesforce's largest customers
Brian Chesky still uses Airbnb and visits hosts
Sara Blakely still talks to Spanx customers about their experiences
The difference is they do it strategically rather than as a bottleneck in the sales process.
Your role isn't disappearing—it's evolving.
Instead of selling to everyone, you'll focus on:
Setting the vision and strategy
Selling to strategic partners and key accounts
Building and developing your team
Ensuring product and market alignment
This evolution isn't a loss. It's growth—for both you and your company.
The right time to hire a salesperson isn't when you're drowning in sales calls. It's when you've built something repeatable enough that someone else can carry it forward while you focus on what only you can do: leading your company into its next phase of growth.
Thank you for reading.
– Scott