Why Most Sales Advice Makes Deals Harder to Win
dailyblog.scottdclary.com
Hi All,
Here’s my daily newsletter navigating the crossroads of business, growth, and life.
If you love this content (please share it), but also…
Start here > https://stan.store/scottdclary
Check out my Podcast, connect with me on YouTube / Twitter, and read my Weekly newsletter.
Sponsor: FreshBooks
The numbers speak for themselves - over 30 million people have chosen FreshBooks, processing more than $60 billion in invoices and saving an incredible 192 hours annually on accounting tasks. As an all-in-one accounting solution, FreshBooks helps entrepreneurs and freelancers create professional estimates, track time, automatically bill clients, and capture expenses on the go - all while integrating seamlessly with over 100 business tools and providing award-winning customer service.
Ready to stop drowning in receipts and chasing payments? Start your 30-day free trial at freshbooks.com - no credit card required.
Plus, if you act before January 7th, get an exclusive Success Story listener offer of 75% off your first three months at freshbooks.com/pricing-offer.
Transform Your Business with FreshBooks
The Closing Trap
Here's what nobody tells you about closing deals: The harder you try to "close," the less likely you are to win the deal.
The data is clear: Sales professionals who use traditional closing techniques are seeing win rates drop by 23% compared to last year. The more they rely on classic closing strategies, the worse they perform.
Think about your own deals right now. You're probably following the standard playbook: Build rapport. Present value. Handle objections. Ask for the close. Follow up. Repeat until you win or lose.
But something's changed. Your prospects are different now. They're more informed, more skeptical, and far less responsive to traditional sales pressure. The same techniques that worked five years ago now make buyers pull back and deals stall.
The numbers tell a fascinating story. High-performing salespeople are actually using fewer closing techniques than their peers. Instead of pushing harder to close, they're taking a radically different approach – and their results are staggering.
But here's what's really interesting: These top performers aren't just doing the opposite of traditional sales wisdom. They've discovered something far more valuable. A completely different way of thinking about what it means to "close" a deal.
In the next few minutes, I'm going to show you exactly what's changed in buyer psychology, why traditional closing techniques backfire, and what actually works in today's environment. Not theory. Not outdated tactics. Real, practical approaches that are working right now.
The Pattern Every Sales Professional Is Facing
The transformation in how deals close isn't random. It's following a clear pattern that's reshaping the entire sales landscape.
Modern buyers have fundamentally changed. They're doing 70% of their research before ever talking to sales. They're comparing options extensively. They're asking harder questions. But most importantly, they're hypersensitive to anything that feels like sales pressure.
This shift has created a fascinating paradox: The moment you try to "close" a deal, you dramatically reduce your chances of winning it.
Think about how deals actually happen today:
Your best deals – the ones that closed smoothly and turned into great customers – probably felt almost effortless. The conversation flowed naturally. The buyer was engaged. The next steps were clear. You weren't really "closing" at all. You were simply facilitating a decision they were already moving toward.
Your worst deals – the ones where you tried every closing technique, followed up relentlessly, and still lost – probably felt like pushing a boulder uphill. Every "closing technique" you used made the buyer more resistant, not less.
Traditional sales wisdom tells us that closing is about finding the right technique for the right moment. Alternate choice close. Assumptive close. Urgency close. The list goes on. But here's what nobody talks about: These techniques don't just fail – they actively damage your chances of winning the deal.
Let's look at what's really happening in modern sales conversations.
When you use a traditional closing technique, you trigger what psychologists call "persuasion resistance." Your buyer's brain immediately activates its defense mechanisms. Even if your offer is perfect for them, the very act of trying to close makes them less likely to buy.
The data proves this out. When salespeople use standard closing techniques:
Trust scores drop
Engagement in calls falls
Follow-up response rates decline
Deal velocity slows
But it gets worse. Every time you use a closing technique that fails, you're not just losing that opportunity to close. You're actually making it harder to close in the future. Your buyer becomes more resistant, more skeptical, and less engaged.
Think about your own buying experiences. When was the last time you enjoyed being "closed"? When was the last time a pushy salesperson made you more likely to buy? When was the last time pressure actually helped you make a better decision?
This is why traditional closing advice is so dangerous. It's not just ineffective – it's counterproductive. It turns interested prospects into resistant buyers. It transforms productive conversations into defensive exchanges. And most importantly, it fundamentally misunderstands how modern buyers make decisions.
The best sellers have figured this out. They've stopped trying to "close" deals entirely. Instead, they're taking a radically different approach that aligns with how people actually make buying decisions in today's world.
The Better Way to Think About Closing
Stop thinking about closing deals. Start thinking about facilitating decisions.
Here's what top performers understand: The best deals close themselves when you create the right conditions. Your job isn't to "close" – it's to help buyers reach their own conclusions.
This shift in thinking changes everything about how you approach sales conversations.
Instead of looking for opportunities to close, top performers focus on three key elements:
Clarity: Making the path to decision crystal clear. Helping buyers understand exactly where they are in their process and what needs to happen next.
Confidence: Building genuine conviction through proof, not persuasion. Letting buyers discover value themselves rather than being told what to value.
Control: Giving buyers control over their journey while guiding the process. Creating momentum without pressure.
This approach actually makes selling easier, not harder. You spend less time following up, less time handling objections, and less time trying to revive stalled deals.
Why? Because you're working with human psychology rather than against it. You're aligning with how people naturally make decisions instead of trying to force decisions through technique.
The best part? Once you understand this approach, you can close bigger deals with less effort and zero pressure. Your deals start closing themselves because you've created the conditions for natural decision-making.
The Decision Facilitation Framework
Let me show you exactly how top performers are closing deals without traditional closing techniques. This isn't theory – it's a practical framework you can start using in your very next sales conversation.
The framework has three core components. Let me show you exactly how each one works in practice:
First: Decision Mapping
Instead of pushing for a close, you're mapping out how your buyer makes decisions. Here's what this looks like in action:
Who needs to be involved: "I notice projects like this usually involve IT and Finance. Who else would need to weigh in on this decision?"
Rather than presuming you know the decision-makers, you help buyers identify them:
"Who else should we bring into these discussions?"
"How does your team typically evaluate solutions like this?"
"Walk me through who would need to sign off on this."
What information they need: Instead of overwhelming them with everything at once, help them identify their critical information needs:
"What would you need to see to feel confident about moving forward?"
"What questions would your CEO ask about this?"
"Which aspects of this solution do you need to understand better?"
Which concerns they need to address: Don't rush to handle objections. Help them surface and prioritize concerns:
"What potential roadblocks do you see?"
"What would make this a difficult decision?"
"Where do you think we might run into resistance?"
How they prefer to move forward: Let them define the path:
"How do you typically move forward with projects like this?"
"What does your ideal timeline look like?"
"What would be the natural next steps in your process?"
Second: Momentum Building
This is where most salespeople rush, but top performers take a different approach. Here's how:
Helping buyers discover value themselves: Instead of telling them the value, help them uncover it:
"How would this impact your current process?"
"What would changing this mean for your team?"
"Walk me through how you'd use this in your day-to-day."
Making next steps obvious and easy: Break down the path forward into clear, manageable steps:
"Based on what you've shared, should we start with a technical review?"
"Would it make sense to do a small pilot first?"
"Should we bring your team in to see this in action?"
Building genuine urgency through insight: Don't create artificial deadlines. Help them see real implications:
"What's the cost of waiting another quarter?"
"How would this impact your upcoming projects?"
"What opportunities are you missing without this in place?"
Letting buyers set the pace while you guide the direction: Follow their timing but keep the process moving:
"What timeline aligns with your goals?"
"When would you want to have this in place?"
"How quickly do you need to address this?"
Third: Commitment Harvesting
This is where traditional closing gets replaced with something more powerful. Here's how:
Listen for buying signals: Pay attention to future-oriented language:
"We could use this for..."
"Our team would probably..."
"This would help us..."
When you hear these, note them. They're natural commitment points.
Reflect their own words back to them: When they show interest, mirror their language:
"You mentioned this would help streamline your reporting process..."
"Earlier you said this would save your team about 10 hours a week..."
"You noted this would solve your compliance challenges..."
Document mutual understanding: Create shared documents that capture progress:
"Let me summarize what we've discussed..."
"Here's what I understand about your needs..."
"I've outlined the key points you've mentioned..."
Make their progress visible: Help them see how far they've come:
"We've covered technical requirements, budget alignment, and team impact. The only remaining piece is..."
"You've already validated the ROI and technical fit. Should we look at implementation timing?"
"We've addressed your main concerns about security and integration. What else do you need to see?"
Putting It All Together
Here's what this might sound like in a real conversation:
"Based on what you've shared, you need to see the security documentation, get IT's sign-off, and understand the implementation timeline. Your team has already validated the ROI, and you've mentioned this would help you meet your Q2 objectives. Should we start with the security review and then bring in IT for a technical deep dive?"
Notice how this doesn't feel like closing at all. You're simply reflecting their progress and suggesting a natural next step based on their own criteria and timeline.
The key is that every part of this framework removes pressure while creating clarity. You're not pushing for a close – you're making it easy for buyers to move forward at their own pace with complete confidence.
Here's what this looks like in practice:
When a buyer says they need to think about it, don't try to close. Instead, help them think about it effectively. Map out what they're considering. Make their decision criteria explicit. Help them see their own progress.
When a buyer seems hesitant, don't push harder. Get curious about their process. Understand what's creating the hesitation. Help them resolve it themselves rather than trying to resolve it for them.
The key is shifting from persuasion to facilitation. Instead of trying to convince buyers to move forward, help them see where they already are in their journey and what they need to move forward naturally.
Making This Work in Real Deals
Let's get practical. Here's exactly how to implement this approach in different sales situations.
For Complex B2B Sales
The key is making progress visible. In your next deal:
Start with a mutual decision plan. Not your sales process – their buying process. Map out exactly what they need to feel confident in a decision. Track progress against their goals, not your quotas.
When stakeholder concerns arise, don't counter them. Capture them. Create a shared document that tracks every concern and its resolution. Make their progress toward confidence visible.
Use language like: "Where are you in your evaluation process?" "What would make this decision easy for you?" "How will you know when you're ready to move forward?"
For High-Ticket Services
Focus on future-pacing. Help prospects experience the value before they buy:
Walk through detailed implementation scenarios
Share specific client success paths
Map their goals to proven processes
Instead of asking for the business, ask questions that reveal their readiness: "How would you see us getting started?" "What timeline makes sense for your goals?" "What would you need to see in place first?"
For Transactional Sales
Speed matters, but pressure kills. Create urgency through insight, not artificial deadlines:
Show them what they're missing now
Make immediate benefits tangible
Highlight hidden costs of delay
When you hear buying signals, don't pounce. Reflect and confirm: "It sounds like you've found what you're looking for..." "I'm hearing that this fits your needs..." "Should we look at next steps?"
Remember: The best closes don't feel like closing at all. They feel like the natural next step in a well-facilitated process.
Where Sales Is Heading
The future of sales isn't about better closing techniques. It's about better buying experiences.
The data shows three major shifts happening:
Buyers are becoming even more self-directed. By 2025, analysts predict that 80% of the buying process will happen before any sales conversation. This means the traditional idea of "closing" will become increasingly irrelevant.
AI is changing the game. But not how most people think. AI won't replace salespeople – it will amplify the difference between facilitators and closers. Those who rely on techniques will become obsolete. Those who excel at guiding decisions will become invaluable.
Trust is becoming the ultimate currency. As information becomes more abundant, the ability to build genuine trust becomes more crucial. Pressure tactics don't just fail – they actively destroy trust at a time when it's most valuable.
What This Means For You
The salespeople who will thrive in this new environment are developing three key abilities:
Decision Intelligence: Understanding how modern buyers make choices and how to facilitate better decisions.
Trust Architecture: Building frameworks that create confidence without pressure.
Process Mastery: Creating repeatable systems for guiding buyers to natural conclusions.
These skills aren't just nice to have. They're becoming essential for survival in sales. The gap between those who master them and those who don't will determine who thrives and who struggles in the years ahead.
Remember This
The best deals don't close through technique. They close through clarity. You don't need more closing strategies. You need better facilitation skills. Your buyers don't need more pressure. They need more clarity.
The future belongs to the facilitators, not the closers.
Scott