Why Your Lead Magnet Isn't Converting (And How to Fix It)
dailyblog.scottdclary.com
Hi All,
Here’s my daily newsletter navigating the crossroads of business, growth, and life.
If you love this content (please share it), but also…
Start here > https://newsletter.scottdclary.com
Check out my Podcast, connect with me on YouTube / Twitter, and read my Weekly newsletter.
Sponsor: Lingoda
Look, I'll be real with you, my French used to be solid. I learned it in school. But when I booked a trip to France a few years ago, it was a total blank. I could barely order a croissant.
So I joined the Lingoda Sprint Challenge. And it changed everything. Live classes, five students max, real teachers. In two months, I went from bonjour to café conversations.
Here's how it works - you take 30 or 60 classes in 60 days, and when you finish, you get 50% of your money back. That works out to about $4.50 per class, which is honestly amazing for live instruction. Let's get fluent.
Listen Here
How to Make a Lead Magnet So Good They'd Pay for It
Your lead magnet sucks.
I don't say that to be mean. I say it because 99% of lead magnets are digital trash that nobody wants.
"Download our 47-page guide to social media marketing!" "Get our exclusive checklist for productivity!" "Sign up for our monthly newsletter with industry insights!"
These aren't lead magnets. They're lead repellents.
Here's the uncomfortable truth: If people wouldn't pay for your lead magnet, they won't value it enough to give you their email address either.
Email addresses aren't free. They cost attention, trust, and inbox real estate. In 2024, those are more valuable than money.
The best lead magnets solve an immediate, painful problem so well that people feel guilty getting them for free. They deliver transformation, not just information.
Let me show you how to build one that makes people wonder why you're not charging for it.
The Fatal Flaw in Most Lead Magnets
Most entrepreneurs think lead magnets are about capturing emails.
Wrong.
Lead magnets are about proving your competence before someone risks their money with you.
Your lead magnet is your first product. If it's mediocre, people assume your paid products are too.
I've seen founders spend $10,000 on Facebook ads driving traffic to lead magnets that convert at 2%. Not because their traffic was bad, but because their lead magnet promised everything and delivered nothing.
The problem isn't your headlines or landing page copy. It's that you're solving imaginary problems with theoretical solutions.
Great lead magnets solve real problems with specific solutions.
Ryan Holiday didn't build his email list with "31 Tips for Better Marketing." He created "The Email That Got Me a Job at American Apparel" - showing exactly how he wrote one email that changed his career trajectory.
Austin Kleon didn't offer "How to Be More Creative." He gave away "Steal Like an Artist" - a complete framework for generating ideas by building on existing work.
These weren't just lead magnets. They were valuable products disguised as free content.
The shift in thinking changes everything about what you create.
The Immediate Problem Test
Before you create anything, ask yourself: What problem does someone have right now that they'd pay to solve today?
Not tomorrow. Not next week. Today.
Most lead magnets fail this test because they address theoretical future problems:
"How to Scale Your Business" (I don't have a business yet) "Advanced SEO Strategies" (I haven't mastered basic SEO) "Building Your Personal Brand" (I don't know what my brand should be)
These topics feel important but aren't urgent. Important without urgency equals ignored.
Urgent problems get attention. Important problems get bookmarked.
Here's how to find urgent problems:
Look at what people pay for immediately
What do people in your space buy without thinking twice? Emergency fixes, last-minute solutions, urgent problems that can't wait.
A web developer noticed clients constantly needed emergency fixes for broken contact forms. Instead of offering "Website Optimization Tips," he created "Fix Your Broken Contact Form in Under 10 Minutes" - with specific code snippets for the 8 most common issues.
Download rate: 47%. Because broken contact forms cost money every hour they stay broken.
Listen to what people complain about repeatedly
Join communities where your ideal customers hang out. What frustrations come up over and over?
A productivity coach noticed entrepreneurs constantly complained about context switching killing their focus. Instead of "Productivity Tips for Entrepreneurs," she created "The 90-Minute Focus Block Template" - showing exactly how to structure uninterrupted work sessions.
The difference? One addresses a vague desire to be more productive. The other solves the specific problem of fractured attention.
Find the gap between knowing and doing
Most people know what they should do. They don't know how to actually do it.
Instead of "Why You Should Start a Newsletter," create "Your First Newsletter Issue Template" - with subject line formulas, content structure, and send timing.
Instead of "The Importance of Customer Feedback," create "5 Questions That Reveal What Customers Actually Want" - with exact scripts and follow-up sequences.
Knowledge is cheap. Implementation is valuable.
Once you've identified an urgent problem, the next challenge is proving you can solve it better than anyone else.
The Credibility Demonstration
Your lead magnet must prove you know what you're talking about before asking for trust.
Most lead magnets make claims without evidence:
"This strategy will transform your business!" "These tips will save you hours every day!" "Follow this framework for guaranteed results!"
Claims without proof are just marketing copy.
Credible lead magnets demonstrate competence through results, not promises.
Show, don't tell your expertise
Instead of claiming you can help people write better, show them the email that generated $50,000 in revenue. Include the subject line, the exact copy, and the results.
Instead of promising to teach social media strategy, share the content calendar that grew an account from 500 to 50,000 followers in 6 months. Show the posts, the engagement rates, the timeline.
Use specific numbers and timelines
"How I Got 1,000 Email Subscribers" is more credible than "How to Build Your Email List" "The $10,000 Sales Page Breakdown" beats "How to Write Better Sales Copy" "30 Days to Your First Freelance Client" trumps "How to Start Freelancing"
Specificity signals authenticity. Vague promises signal amateur hour.
Include the behind-the-scenes story
People don't just want the result. They want to understand the thinking behind it.
Noah Kagan's lead magnets often include his thought process: why he chose certain strategies, what didn't work, what he'd do differently.
This transparency builds trust faster than polished case studies that hide the messy reality of execution.
But demonstrating credibility is just the foundation. The real value comes from making your solution immediately actionable.
The Implementation Advantage
Most lead magnets give people more to think about. The best ones give people something to do.
Information without implementation is just entertainment.
Your lead magnet should enable someone to take action within 24 hours of downloading it.
This means:
Providing templates, not just strategies
Instead of "How to Write Cold Emails," give them "5 Cold Email Templates That Book Meetings" - with fill-in-the-blank scripts for different scenarios.
Instead of "Content Planning Strategies," create "The 30-Day Content Calendar Template" - with post ideas, hashtag suggestions, and optimal posting times.
Including specific tools and resources
Don't just tell them what to do. Tell them exactly how to do it.
If you're teaching email marketing, include recommended tools, setup instructions, and configuration screenshots.
If you're sharing design principles, provide color palettes, font pairings, and free design tools.
Creating step-by-step processes
Break complex tasks into simple sequences.
"Launch Your First Product in 30 Days" should include daily actions, not general advice. Day 1: validate your idea with this survey template. Day 2: create your landing page using this copy framework. Day 3: set up your payment processing with these exact steps.
Making success measurable
Tell people exactly what success looks like and how to measure it.
Instead of "improve your writing," define success as "reduce your editing time by 50% using this review checklist."
Instead of "better time management," specify "reclaim 2 hours daily using this task prioritization system."
This implementation focus separates valuable lead magnets from digital clutter.
The Format and Positioning That Wins
After you’ve crafted the perfect lead magnet, the last item you need to pay attention to is how you package it.
Choose format based on consumption preference, not creation ease
Most founders default to PDF guides because they're easy to create. Easy to create usually means easy to ignore.
Match your format to how people want to consume solutions:
Templates and checklists for process-heavy problems people reference repeatedly
Short video series for skill-building that requires practice
Interactive tools for problems needing personalized solutions
A social media strategist could create a PDF guide about content planning (easy to create, hard to implement) or a content calendar template (easy to implement, immediate value).
The template wins because it removes friction between download and implementation.
The Guilt-Free Giveaway Test
Here's the ultimate test for your lead magnet:
If you charged $97 for this, would people feel like they got a good deal?
If not, keep improving until the answer is yes.
This doesn't mean your lead magnet needs to be as comprehensive as a paid product. It means the value per minute of consumption should be extraordinarily high.
A 10-page guide that saves someone 10 hours of work is more valuable than a 100-page guide full of obvious advice.
The best lead magnets solve one problem completely rather than touching on ten problems superficially.
Quality beats quantity every time.
When you've created something people would happily pay for, giving it away for free creates massive goodwill and trust.
This is how you build an audience of people who think: "If this is what they give away for free, their paid products must be incredible."
That's when lead magnets become lead accelerants - turning strangers into customers faster than any sales process ever could.
The goal isn't just to capture emails. It's to create such a remarkable first impression that people can't wait to see what you'll offer them next.
Your lead magnet is your first product. Make it your best product.
And watch how many people become eager to pay for whatever comes after.
Thank you for reading.
– Scott
Another solid read.