Your Empowerment Strategy Is Backfiring (Here's Why)

dailyblog.scottdclary.com

Dec 17, 2024

Hi All,

Here’s my daily newsletter navigating the crossroads of business, growth, and life.

If you love this content (please share it), but also…

Start here > https://stan.store/scottdclary

Check out my Podcast, connect with me on YouTube / Twitter, and read my Weekly newsletter.

Sponsor: LinkedIn

Hiring the right people is a make-or-break situation for small businesses. That's why I consistently use LinkedIn Jobs. It's the best way to access a vast network of top-tier professionals – something you won't find on generic job boards. LinkedIn's platform simplifies the entire hiring process, something incredibly important when you're juggling a million other responsibilities.

Also, they have a ton of tools that can help you like the job description builder…. it’s a lifesavers.

It's easy to see why millions of small businesses choose LinkedIn for their hiring needs.

Elevate your hiring process – post your next job opening for free at linkedin.com/EXCELLENCE. You’ll experience firsthand why LinkedIn Jobs is the go-to choice for finding exceptional talent. (Terms and conditions apply.)

Post Your Next Job

A Journey of Transformation

I'll never forget the moment it hit me. It was 11 PM, and I was still at my desk, drowning in other people's problems. My team had grown from 5 to 50, our business was booming, and I was more miserable than ever. That's when I realized a painful truth: I had become the bottleneck in my own organization.

Every leader has that moment when they realize they can't solve everything themselves. For some, it comes during a late-night strategy session. For others, it hits during their third consecutive weekend at the office. For me, it was that quiet moment when I understood that my need to solve every problem wasn't just hurting me – it was holding back my entire team.

The journey we'll take together today will transform how we think about leadership and what's possible when we truly empower others. This isn't just another management theory or leadership framework. It's a fundamental shift in how we approach our role as leaders.

The greatest gift we can give our teams isn't having all the answers – it's helping them find their own. When we make this shift, we don't just build better organizations, we build better leaders at every level. The path forward isn't about becoming a better problem solver; it's about becoming a better problem distributor.

Why Everything is Different Now

We're living through the biggest shift in how work gets done since the industrial revolution. The old models of leadership aren't just less effective – they're actively holding us back. The command-and-control structures that built the modern economy are now its greatest liability.

Think about it: When was the last time you faced a challenge that could be solved with a simple top-down directive? The problems we face today are too nuanced, too interconnected, and too complex for any one person to solve alone. The real question isn't whether to change, but how quickly we can adapt.

The traditional "hero leader" approach is failing for a simple reason: It wasn't designed for a world where:

Information moves at the speed of light
Markets transform overnight
Innovation comes from anywhere
Talent has unlimited options
Complexity grows exponentially

The End of the Hero Leader

Remember the last time you stayed late trying to solve everyone's problems? We've all been there, wondering why there aren't enough hours in the day to keep up. The calendar is packed with back-to-back meetings, your inbox is overflowing with decisions only you can make, and somewhere in between, you're supposed to be setting strategy and developing your team.

The traditional leadership model is breaking because of five fundamental shifts in how work gets done:

Problems are too complex for one person: The challenges we face today don't just require more knowledge – they require different kinds of knowledge working together. No single leader, no matter how brilliant, can hold all the pieces.
Innovation needs multiple perspectives: The best ideas rarely come from the top anymore. They emerge from the collision of different viewpoints, experiences, and insights across the organization.
Speed requires distributed decision-making: In a world where markets change overnight, waiting for decisions to flow up and down the hierarchy isn't just slow – it's dangerous. Teams need the authority to move when opportunity strikes.
Talent demands autonomy :The best people don't want to be micromanaged. They want clear goals, necessary resources, and the freedom to achieve results their way.
Competition requires full team engagement: Success today requires everyone bringing their full creativity and capability to work. We can't compete if only the leaders are fully engaged.

The days of the all-knowing leader are over, not because it wasn't good, but because it's no longer enough. Today's challenges require unlocking the potential of every team member.

The Cost of Control

Every time we jump in to solve a problem for our team, we pay a price we can't see. Every decision we make that could be made by others comes with hidden costs that compound over time.

It's like taking out a high-interest loan against our organization's future.

The real costs of maintaining control:

Slower decision-making: When every decision requires leader input, the organization moves at the speed of the leader's availability. In a world where speed matters, this is a death by a thousand delays.
Reduced innovation: Teams that need permission to try new things eventually stop trying. The cost isn't just in the ideas we reject – it's in the ideas that never get proposed.
Lower team engagement: People join organizations to make an impact. When we solve their problems for them, we don't just rob them of growth opportunities – we rob them of their primary motivation.
Limited scalability: Organizations dependent on leader decision-making can only grow as far as their leaders can stretch. This creates an invisible ceiling on growth that many never recognize until it's too late.
Increased burnout: Leaders trying to solve everything eventually break. The human cost of hero leadership isn't just in stress and exhaustion – it's in the talented leaders we lose because they can't sustain the impossible.

Holding on too tightly doesn't just hurt our teams – it eventually breaks our organizations. The path forward requires a fundamental shift in how we think about leadership.

Understanding True Empowerment

What Empowerment Really Means

Every time we talk about empowerment, someone thinks we're just delegating work we don't want to do. But real empowerment is about something much deeper and more powerful. It's about creating the conditions for others to operate at their full potential.

True empowerment means providing:

Authority to make meaningful decisions: Not just the small stuff, but real decisions that impact the business. When people know their decisions matter, they make them more carefully and thoughtfully than when they're just making recommendations.
Resources to execute effectively: Authority without resources is frustration in disguise. True empowerment means ensuring people have the tools, budget, and access they need to succeed.
Support when challenges arise: This isn't about abandoning people to sink or swim. It's about being there as a resource and guide while resisting the urge to take over.
Trust to try new approaches: Innovation requires the freedom to deviate from "how we've always done it." When we truly trust our teams, we open the door to breakthrough thinking.
Freedom to learn from failure: Without the safety to fail, people will always choose the safest path. Real empowerment includes the space to make mistakes and grow from them.

This isn't about giving up control – it's about multiplying impact across the organization. When we truly empower others, we don't become less powerful – we create more power throughout the system.

Creating the Right Environment

Think about your team's last big innovation – the one that really moved the needle.

Chances are it didn't come from a formal brainstorming session or a top-down initiative.

It probably emerged from an environment where someone felt safe enough to challenge conventional wisdom, took a calculated risk, and had the support to see it through.

The greatest barrier to empowerment isn't skill or strategy – it's environment. We can have all the right intentions, understand our own leadership patterns, and master the principles of delegation. But if we haven't created the right conditions for empowerment to thrive, we're building on sand.

In the next few sections, we'll explore three critical elements of an empowering environment: psychological safety that makes risk-taking possible, a failure-tolerant culture that accelerates learning, and centered leadership that provides stability in chaos. These aren't just nice-to-haves – they're the foundation that makes everything else we've discussed possible.

The shift from controlling to empowering isn't just about what we do – it's about the space we create for others to step into their full potential. Let's start with the game-changer Google discovered in their quest to build perfect teams...

Psychological Safety: The Game Changer

We all know that sinking feeling when we're afraid to speak up in a meeting. The idea that feels too risky to share. The question we're afraid might make us look stupid. Now imagine leading in a way that ensures no one on your team ever feels that fear.

Google's groundbreaking research showed something fascinating about high-performing teams. It wasn't about having the smartest people or the most experienced leaders. It was about creating an environment where people felt safe to take risks.

Their research revealed:

Safety matters more than individual talent: Teams with average performers but high psychological safety outperformed teams of top performers who didn't feel safe.
Trust enables peak performance: When people know they won't be punished for mistakes, they bring their best ideas forward.
Innovation requires vulnerability: New ideas are fragile. They need protection and nurturing before they're ready for harsh criticism.
Teams need space to fail: The fastest-learning teams aren't the ones that never fail – they're the ones that fail fast and learn faster.
Learning happens through open dialogue: Real learning requires honest conversation about what's working and what isn't.

When people feel safe, magic happens – ideas flow, innovation accelerates, and problems get solved faster than ever. Safety isn't just about feeling good – it's about performing better.

Building a Failure-Tolerant Culture

Remember the last great innovation that worked perfectly the first time? Neither do we. Yet somehow we've created organizations that expect perfection from day one. This paradox is killing innovation and stifling growth in companies everywhere.

Creating space for productive failure:

Celebrate learning attempts: Don't just celebrate successes – celebrate bold attempts that generate valuable insights. The team that fails fast and learns is more valuable than the team that never takes risks.
Share lessons openly: Make learning from failure a public process. When leaders share their own failures and lessons learned, they create permission for others to do the same.
Support calculated risks: There's a difference between reckless failure and intelligent experimentation. Create clear guardrails that make it safe to take smart risks.
Focus on growth: Every failure is an opportunity for development. The question shouldn't be "who messed up?" but "what did we learn?"
Measure learning, not just results: Include learning metrics in your performance evaluations. What did we learn? How will we apply it? What's next?

When we make it safe to fail smart and fail forward, we unlock levels of innovation we never thought possible. The fastest-learning organization usually wins in the long run.

Centered Leadership in Practice

Ever notice how some leaders remain calm in chaos while others amplify the panic? The difference isn't in what they do – it's in how they show up. Their presence either creates stability or spreads anxiety throughout the organization.

Centered leadership means:

Staying calm under pressure: Your emotional state is contagious. When you maintain composure, you help others do the same.
Listening deeply, not just hearing: Beyond hearing words, understand the concerns, fears, and aspirations behind them. People know when you're really present.
Responding thoughtfully, not reacting: The space between stimulus and response is where leadership happens. Take that extra moment to choose your response.
Being fully present: In a world of constant distraction, your focused attention is a powerful gift. When you're there, be really there.
Modeling balanced behavior: Show what sustainable high performance looks like. It's not about working longer – it's about working better.

Our teams can only be as steady as we are. When we find our center, we give others permission to find theirs. This isn't just about personal practice – it's about creating an environment where everyone can do their best work.

Transformation in Action

Microsoft's Cultural Revolution

When Satya Nadella took over Microsoft, many thought the company's best days were behind it. The stock had been flat for a decade, morale was low, and competitors were innovating faster. The real problem wasn't technology – it was a culture that valued knowing over learning.

The transformation focused on:

Shifting from "know-it-all" to "learn-it-all" Instead of rewarding people for having answers, they started celebrating those who asked good questions and learned quickly.
Encouraging partnership over competition They dismantled internal competing silos and incentivized cross-team collaboration. Success became about collective wins.
Supporting bold moves beyond Windows They embraced cloud computing, open source, and platforms beyond Windows – ideas that were once considered heretical.
Building psychological safety at scale They created systems and processes that made it safe to experiment, fail, and learn across a massive organization.

The result wasn't just a $2.2T market cap – it was proof that even the largest organizations can transform through empowerment. Culture change isn't just possible – it's profitable.

Netflix Breaks the Rules

Most companies start with policies and add more when problems arise. Netflix asked a different question: What if we trusted people instead? Their radical approach to leadership and culture challenged everything we thought we knew about managing at scale.

The radical approach included:

No vacation policy Instead of tracking time off, they focused on measuring results and impact. Trust people to manage their own time.
No expense regulations Replace rules with context. Trust people to spend company money as if it were their own.
High freedom, high responsibility Give people the autonomy to make decisions, but hold them accountable for outcomes.
Context over control Instead of telling people what to do, ensure they have the context to make good decisions themselves.

The lesson wasn't that rules are bad – it's that trust is better. When we treat people like adults, they usually exceed our expectations.

Pixar's Creative Secret

Every great Pixar movie started as a bad movie. This isn't a criticism – it's their superpower. They've built an entire system around making it safe to be bad on the way to being great.

The "Braintrust" approach:

Regular honest feedback Create structured opportunities for candid feedback, but make it about making the work better, not criticizing the creator.
No power dynamics Take authority out of the room. Good ideas can come from anywhere, and the best idea wins regardless of who suggested it.
Focus on problems, not solutions Point out what isn't working, but trust the creative team to find the solution. Notes should identify issues, not prescribe fixes.
Directors maintain creative control Despite intense feedback, the creative vision remains with the director. This ensures clear ownership while maintaining psychological safety.

Creating safety for "ugly babies" (early ideas) doesn't just work in animation – it works anywhere innovation matters. Excellence isn't about getting it right the first time.

Making It Happen

Starting Small, Thinking Big

Every great transformation started with a single step. The key isn't to change everything at once – it's to start somewhere meaningful and build momentum through success. This isn't about revolution; it's about evolution.

Begin with:

One team or project: Choose a contained environment where you can experiment safely. Look for a team that's ready for more autonomy and a challenge that matters.
Clear decision rights: Be explicit about what decisions they can make independently. Nothing kills empowerment faster than unclear boundaries.
Explicit support: Make it publicly known that you're backing this team's autonomy. Your visible support creates safety for experimentation.
Regular feedback: Create tight feedback loops to learn what's working and what isn't. Adjust quickly based on real experience.
Celebrated attempts: Recognize not just successes, but bold attempts and valuable learnings. The story you tell about this experiment will shape future ones.

Small wins create momentum for bigger changes. Success in one area builds confidence for the next challenge.

Measuring What Matters

We've all heard "what gets measured gets managed." But are we measuring the right things when it comes to empowerment? Traditional metrics often miss the most important indicators of organizational health and capability.

Look for:

Decision-making speed: Track how long it takes to make different types of decisions. Are things getting faster or slower?
Innovation attempts: Count not just successful innovations, but how many new ideas are being tried. A rising number shows increasing psychological safety.
Team engagement: Monitor how actively people participate in decisions and improvements. Are more voices being heard?
Problem-solving at source: Track where problems get solved. Are issues being handled at the lowest appropriate level?
Learning from failure: Measure how openly failures are discussed and what actions result from lessons learned.

The true measures of empowerment aren't just in results – they're in how those results are achieved. Sometimes the most important metrics are qualitative.

Your Next Steps

Today's insights only matter if they lead to tomorrow's actions. The journey starts with choices we make right now.

Begin by:

Identifying one area to empower: Choose a specific team or decision area where you can start shifting control.
Creating safety for your team: Take concrete steps to make it safer to experiment and learn.
Practicing centered leadership: Work on your own ability to stay balanced and present.
Sharing your learnings: Start telling stories that reinforce the culture you want to create.

Remember: The goal isn't perfection – it's progress. Every great leader started exactly where you are now. The question isn't whether to begin this journey, but how soon you can start.

The future belongs to organizations that can unlock the full potential of their people.

Will you be one of them?

Scott

10 Minute MBA

Discussion about this post